Cast 53

1. 

   Keegan-Michael Key

   Jack

2. 

   Gillian Jacobs

   Samantha

3. 

   Chris Gethard

   Bill

4. 

   Kate Micucci

   Allison

5. 

   Tami Sagher

   Lindsay

6. 

   Mike Birbiglia

   Miles

7. 

   Richard Masur

   Lou

8. 

   Sondra James

   Bonnie

9. 

   Richard Kline

   Mr. Coughlin

10. 

    Emily Skeggs

    Shy Sarah

11. 

    Brandon Scott Jones

    Audience Chuck

12. 

    Sunita Mani

    Amy

13. 

    Glenn Wein

    Psychiatrist

14. Neil Fleischer

    Pianist Seth

15. 

    Erin Darke

    Natasha

16. 

    Gary Richardson

    Gary

17. 

    Steve Waltien

    Hugh Finn

18. 

    Kati Rediger

    Alicia Bonham

19. Hallie Bulleit

    Audience Claudia

20. 

    Garth Kravits

    Doctor

21. Jason C. Brown

    Studio Page

22. 

    Pete Holmes

    Self

23. 

    Seth Barrish

    Timothy

24. 

    Miranda Bailey

    Producer

25. 

    Adam Pally

    Robbie

26. Matthew Star

    Improv Student

27. Josh Rabinowitz

    Josh

28. Maggie Kemper

    Liz

29. 

    Lena Dunham

    Self

30. Ben Elkins

    ELEL

31. Jo-Jo Jackson

    ELEL

32. Tim Cook

    ELEL

33. Zach Tichenor

    ELEL

34. Steve Frederick

    ELEL

35. Frderick Weathersby

    ELEL

36. Alex Mojaverian

    ELEL

37. Gavin Speiller

    Autograph Speaker

38. 

    Ben Stiller

    Self

39. Jordan Kenneth Kamp

    Audience Jim

40. 

    Colby Minifie

    Audience Neil

41. 

    Rachel Pegram

    Audience Sarah

42. Tim Martin

    Audience Tony

43. 

    Robert King

    Heckler

44. 

    Kevin Barnett

    Writer Terry

45. Brian Edwards

    Bouncer

46. 

    Jo Firestone

    Jo

47. 

    Connor Ratliff

    Connor

48. Elise Edwards

    Improv Intern (uncredited)

49. DeWitt Fleming Jr.

    Subway Bucket Drummer (uncredited)

50. 

    Ira Glass

    Man on TV (uncredited)

51. Annamaria Sofillas

    Audience Member (uncredited)

52. Sean Toney

    Audience Member (uncredited)

53. 

    Jo Yang

    Sewing Lady (uncredited)

Crew 10