Mike e Rio recebem o grande evento da temporada de futebol universitário. Porém, ninguém em Bucksnort acredita que eles darão conta.

As mulheres vão à Omaha para os exames ginecológicos, mas a viagem sai dos trilhos. Com ciúmes do novo perfil de Beau em um app de encontros, Kay está determinada em achar um cara.

Mike volta ao jornalismo revigorando o jornal da cidade, mas acaba causando muita confusão ao descobrir alguns segredos e rivalidades.

Mike e Rio se conheceram em um Halloween anos atrás. Então, Mike comemora a data assustando Rio a noite toda, sem desconfiar que ela odeia os sustos.

Donna decide viajar de última hora ao Nebraska com o intuito de descansar.

Mike e Rio entram em conflito quando consideram ter um filho, e logo podem experimentar a paternidade quando são forçados a cuidar dos seis leitões de Portia.

Rio tenta ajudar Kay a superar o ciúmes de sua irmã, Stacey, que está visitando a cidade, mas logo fica com ciúmes de Stacey quando descobre que Mike e ela namoravam.

Mike e Rio estão entusiasmados para o seu primeiro Natal juntos como casal, mas um balde de água fria é lançado em seus planos quando problemas não param de surgir.

Mike e Rio precisam decidir quais sementes eles querem começar a cultivar na fazenda, mas Rio está distraída com o seu próprio projeto.

Rio fica chateada por não poder ir até a Islândia para o casamento de sua amiga.

Rio está animada para planejar o casamento perfeito para a sua melhor amiga Sierra na fazenda.

Rio comes up with a plan when Sierra confesses something big on her wedding day, while Mike and Rudy devise a plan to make money from the New Yorkers who are coming in for the wedding. Meanwhile, Beau and Kay fall back into their old arguments and soon find themselves at a crossroads.

When faced with choosing between meat judging (his dad Beau's preference) or playing music (his shared bond with Mike), Jacob realizes he must figure out what his passions are on his own. Meanwhile, Rio takes driving lessons from Kay, but their friendship hits a bump in the road when Kay learns that Rio has secretly been getting lessons from other townspeople.

When the new pastor in town starts giving out free advice to the townspeople, Rio feels like her therapy practice is in jeopardy; Mike falls in love with a used truck and purchases it without telling Rio.

While cleaning out the basement, Rio jokes about Mike’s lack of follow-through when it comes to his hobbies and various projects. Hurt by this comment, Mike sets out to prove Rio wrong. Meanwhile, Constance struggles to end her romantic endeavors with Pastor Paul who has become quite clingy.

Kay asks Mike and Rio to help chaperone Jacob's after-prom event at the community center. After realizing how controlling Kay has been of Jacob's life, Rio tries to encourage her to relinquish control, especially when it comes to his "bad girl" girlfriend Janine. At the same time, Mike recognizes that Beau is upset about Jacob going to college, and he tries to get Beau drunk at the after-prom in order to get him to talk about his feelings.

Mike's family comes to Bucksnort to surprise him for his birthday; a shocking family secret involving Rudy is unveiled; Constance and Clara attempt to help Brandon find a girlfriend via online dating apps.

When a wealthy restaurateur named Dolores comes to Bucksnort with plans to open a new diner right outside of town, Mike jumps at the chance to earn her business as her egg supplier. After Mike seeks out help from Beau with his pitch to Dolores, Beau attempts to get the business for himself, having just found out they are in a financial pinch. While Dolores is in town, she finds romantic interest in Rudy, and he quickly finds himself having a sugar-mama/sugar-baby relationship with her.

When a tornado touches down in Bucksnort, everyone's concerns about their current situations are heightened; Mike and Beau are still at odds about their egg businesses; a mix-up with pregnancy tests leads to confusion.