Debate Gold Diggers of 1933
Discutir → Películas → Gold Diggers of 1933 → Problemas de contenido
Reported Problem for Gold Diggers of 1933
publicado por xtimmyxSTAFFMOD el 7 de mayo de 2022 a las 19:37
Item: Gold Diggers of 1933
Language: en-US
Type of Problem: Incorrect_content
Extra Details: Genre section should be unlocked to be able to add music/musical (the main genre of the film)
Contestado por redhopper
el 10 de septiembre de 2022 a las 00:16
Someone please fix this, this movie is very obviously a musical.
Contestado por superboy97
el 10 de septiembre de 2022 a las 01:24
"music" genre is only for concerts and this sort of things. So, it doesn't apply here.
"musical" genre doesn't exist. It should be added as keyword, which is already the case.
So, there are nothing to change here.
Contestado por redhopper
el 10 de septiembre de 2022 a las 01:38
If this is the case why are there thousands of movie musicals tagged with the genre "music"?
Contestado por superboy97
el 10 de septiembre de 2022 a las 01:42
This is explicitely written in the rule. I quote : "The "Music" genre should only be used for concerts, music documentaries and any films in which music is a key plot element. The "musical" keyword should be used for musical films."
Feel free to report the movies that you think shouldn't have the "music" genre.
Contestado por redhopper
el 10 de septiembre de 2022 a las 01:49
The movie we are talking about here is about the production of a Broadway musical, it seems like it would fit this definition of the genre of "Music"
Contestado por superboy97
el 10 de septiembre de 2022 a las 01:54
It is about the production of a Broadway musical, but not about the music itself.
This explain why it have the keyword "musical" as indicated in the rule.
Contestado por xtimmyx
el 10 de septiembre de 2022 a las 10:51
"any films in which music is a key plot element"
This is a movie with extensive scenes where people are working on writing and then performing music numbers. It absolutely matches the definition in the rule you quoted. The music is a key plot element of the film. To say otherwise is absurd and indicative of being unfamiliar with the film.