Rogue One was garbage for, despite all the crappy shoehorning (the Cantina guys was the absolute worst imo) trying to link it in with the established universe, they utterly failed to make it have any continuity with either ANH or the prequels! It was a massive red flag for what was to follow in TLJ...
Agreed. While it had nice visuals for the most part (excepting Tarkin and Leia, and perhaps a couple other items), it didn't fit neatly into the canon in many respects. Very often, I've heard people deride VII or VIII, but then make allowances for Rogue One or Solo. At this point, I just tune them out.
WAY TOO SERIOUS FOLKS..THE ORIGINAL TRILOGY IS LEGENDARY.THE PREQUELS ARE GARBAGE.FORCE AWAKENS IS FUN IN A NOSTALGIA INDUCING YET UNORIGINAL WAY,ROGUE ONE WAS FUN AND WELL ROUNDED,THE LAST JEDI IS HALF OK AND HALF WTF.EACH PIECE DOES NOT NEED TO FIT PERFECTLY AS SO MANY PIECES ARE ALREADY JACKED UP.WHAT EVER HAPPENED TO JUDGING A FILM BASED ON THE FILM?
Can't find a movie or TV show? Login to create it.
Reply by VHS-VANDAL
on February 16, 2019 at 8:35 PM
NO.JUST NO.IT FITS JUST FINE AND ITS ENTERTAINING AND LOADED WITH COOL CHARACTERS.JADED FANBOYS ARE IRRITATING.
Reply by tmdb33747247
on February 18, 2019 at 5:14 PM
Agreed. While it had nice visuals for the most part (excepting Tarkin and Leia, and perhaps a couple other items), it didn't fit neatly into the canon in many respects. Very often, I've heard people deride VII or VIII, but then make allowances for Rogue One or Solo. At this point, I just tune them out.
Reply by VHS-VANDAL
on February 18, 2019 at 5:33 PM
WAY TOO SERIOUS FOLKS..THE ORIGINAL TRILOGY IS LEGENDARY.THE PREQUELS ARE GARBAGE.FORCE AWAKENS IS FUN IN A NOSTALGIA INDUCING YET UNORIGINAL WAY,ROGUE ONE WAS FUN AND WELL ROUNDED,THE LAST JEDI IS HALF OK AND HALF WTF.EACH PIECE DOES NOT NEED TO FIT PERFECTLY AS SO MANY PIECES ARE ALREADY JACKED UP.WHAT EVER HAPPENED TO JUDGING A FILM BASED ON THE FILM?