A singer and her dog move next door to a widowed father, his little girl and her cat. Despite a rough start, the neighbors grow close, just in time for a Christmas wish to be granted thanks to their devoted pets.

O mundo de Holly vira de cabeça para baixo quando ela descobre que não pode mais mentir graças ao pedido da sobrinha Anna ao Papai Noel. Enquanto sua carreira e vida amorosa desmoronam, ela precisa aprender a distinguir as situações verdadeiras.

When little Lucy wishes it were Christmas every day, "forever and ever", her dad tells the cautionary tale of her grandmother Tilly, who, as a little girl, made the very same wish, and the dire consequences that occurred after her wish was granted.