Season Regulars 5

1. 

   Alia Shawkat

   Dory Sief

2. 

   John Reynolds

   Drew Gardner

3. 

   John Early

   Elliott Goss

4. 

   Meredith Hagner

   Portia Davenport

5. 

   Brandon Micheal Hall

   Julian Marcus

Guest Stars 23

1. 

   Katie Maguire

   Miranda

2. 

   Simone Black

   Maggie

3. 

   Buzz Bovshow

   Richard

4. 

   Diane Ciesla

   Nancy

5. 

   Sydney Farley

   Poem Friend #2

6. Samantha Gambuzza

   A Capella #2

7. 

   Sas Goldberg

   Leslie

8. 

   Suzanne Hevner

   Woman at Vigil #3

9. Peak Kwinarian

   Man at Vigil #2

10. Eden Orshan

    A Capella #1

11. Ruby Pine

    Violin Girl

12. 

    Rebecca Robles

    Poem Friend #1

13. Sonia Valentín

    Woman at Vigil #1

14. 

    Susan Ziegler

    Woman at Vigil #2

15. Rory Duffy

    Vigil Attendee (uncredited)

16. 

    Griffin Newman

    Gavin Rolf

17. 

    William Ragsdale

    Chuck

18. 

    Connor Ratliff

    Ted

19. 

    Jennifer Kim

    Agnes Cho

20. James Young

    Robert Witherbottom

21. 

    Bonnie Milligan

    Katherine Witherbottom

22. 

    Catherine Lloyd Burns

    Linda Witherbottom

23. 

    Christine Taylor

    Gail

Crew 3