@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@revelle said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@revelle said:

I don't think it's the David Hamilton murder either because Laura's name would be in the file, since she confessed to it.

I think it could be the Theresa Carter case. If I remember the retcon right, Rick and Scotty buried her body. So if the body was never found, then it's a missing persons case. Or if it turns out that the body was eventually found, maybe it's a cold case file in homicide. Either way, I dont think Laura's name would be in that file. IIRC, no one knows she murdered Theresa except for Scott and later on, Luke.

Good point about Theresa not having a file. The theory is David is alive and is related to Cyrus. David is the one Cyrus has been sending money to at the house in Astoria.

How old was Laura when she killed David? Because if this is about that case, the only reason I can think of why the file might be heavily redacted and her name not in the file is because Laura was a minor...?? But I don't know how old her character was supposed to be then...

Another thing to ponder is that Laura called Scott after Jordan showed her the file. Scott was involved in the cover up in the Carter murder. So it would make sense that she would give Scott a heads up if Cyrus is sniffing around it. If the file was about David's murder, why would Laura call Scott?

See, that’s why I thought it originally was about Theresa. I guess there could technically be a missing person file about her.

Laura was dating Scott when she had an affair with David which was considered statutory rape so she must have been under 18 at the time. She confessed to murdering David and the charges against Lesley were dropped. Laura was sentenced to six months probation as David’s death was accidental and she was released into Lesley and Rick's custody.

Thanks for that info, I wasn't sure. Whichever case it ends up being, I'm interested in what they do with it.

@amyspen said:

I considered the Theresa Carter case, too, but Scotty said he had very little to do with the case. Could helping Rick bury a body be considered "very little" to do with it--- even if that detail never actually came up in the investigation? I should rewatch the scene, though.

Like pretty much everyone who liked Rick, I hated the Theresa rewrite. I hope this is about David Hamilton.

Good point about what Scott said. I'm still on the fence. I just don't see why Laura would go to Scott about the David case resurfacing. Unless it's only that she's reaching out to him for support because of their complicated relationship & bc he was in her life at that time.

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

Professor David Hamilton had two children and a wife who were killed in the wreckage of his home. David was left paralyzed. It’s possible Cyrus was one of the children and survived.

What??? I remember the David Hamilton storyline but I don't remember anything about him having a wife, 2 kids, a house collapse or him being paralyzed. What I remember is he was a friend of Rick Webber's, teenager Laura had a affair with him and then killed him by bashing him over the head with one of his own art sculptures. Lesley took the rap for it and went to prison for a while until Laura confessed.

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

Professor David Hamilton had two children and a wife who were killed in the wreckage of his home. David was left paralyzed. It’s possible Cyrus was one of the children and survived.

What??? I remember the David Hamilton storyline but I don't remember anything about him having a wife, 2 kids, a house collapse or him being paralyzed. What I remember is he was a friend of Rick Webber's, teenager Laura had a affair with him and then killed him by bashing him over the head with one of his own art sculptures. Lesley took the rap for it and went to prison for a while until Laura confessed.

That was his backstory. I don’t think any of his family was ever seen.

David was tried to seduce Lesley in revenge as David's late wife had apparently always been in love with Rick.

Also I thought Laura pushed David and he fell and hit his head on the hearth and died.

So Cyrus is tied to DH!

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

Professor David Hamilton had two children and a wife who were killed in the wreckage of his home. David was left paralyzed. It’s possible Cyrus was one of the children and survived.

What??? I remember the David Hamilton storyline but I don't remember anything about him having a wife, 2 kids, a house collapse or him being paralyzed. What I remember is he was a friend of Rick Webber's, teenager Laura had a affair with him and then killed him by bashing him over the head with one of his own art sculptures. Lesley took the rap for it and went to prison for a while until Laura confessed.

That was his backstory. I don’t think any of his family was ever seen.

David was tried to seduce Lesley in revenge as David's late wife had apparently always been in love with Rick.

Also I thought Laura pushed David and he fell and hit his head on the hearth and died.

No, none of David's family was ever seen. I know that for sure. I had completely forgotten his backstory and even hearing it now, I don't remember it. But I'll take everybody's word for it. I'm almost certain Laura bashed him in the head with one of his own statues/sculptures. I can almost picture her doing that. Maybe somebody else here will remember?

I started watching in 78. and that was the fallout from Lesley's trial. I missed the actual sheeze.

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

Professor David Hamilton had two children and a wife who were killed in the wreckage of his home. David was left paralyzed. It’s possible Cyrus was one of the children and survived.

What??? I remember the David Hamilton storyline but I don't remember anything about him having a wife, 2 kids, a house collapse or him being paralyzed. What I remember is he was a friend of Rick Webber's, teenager Laura had a affair with him and then killed him by bashing him over the head with one of his own art sculptures. Lesley took the rap for it and went to prison for a while until Laura confessed.

That was his backstory. I don’t think any of his family was ever seen.

David was tried to seduce Lesley in revenge as David's late wife had apparently always been in love with Rick.

Also I thought Laura pushed David and he fell and hit his head on the hearth and died.

No, none of David's family was ever seen. I know that for sure. I had completely forgotten his backstory and even hearing it now, I don't remember it. But I'll take everybody's word for it. I'm almost certain Laura bashed him in the head with one of his own statues/sculptures. I can almost picture her doing that. Maybe somebody else here will remember?

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

Professor David Hamilton had two children and a wife who were killed in the wreckage of his home. David was left paralyzed. It’s possible Cyrus was one of the children and survived.

What??? I remember the David Hamilton storyline but I don't remember anything about him having a wife, 2 kids, a house collapse or him being paralyzed. What I remember is he was a friend of Rick Webber's, teenager Laura had a affair with him and then killed him by bashing him over the head with one of his own art sculptures. Lesley took the rap for it and went to prison for a while until Laura confessed.

That was his backstory. I don’t think any of his family was ever seen.

David was tried to seduce Lesley in revenge as David's late wife had apparently always been in love with Rick.

Also I thought Laura pushed David and he fell and hit his head on the hearth and died.

No, none of David's family was ever seen. I know that for sure. I had completely forgotten his backstory and even hearing it now, I don't remember it. But I'll take everybody's word for it. I'm almost certain Laura bashed him in the head with one of his own statues/sculptures. I can almost picture her doing that. Maybe somebody else here will remember?

Phil Brewer was killed when he was bludgeoned with a geode by Augusta McLeod. Are you thinking of that murder?

@revelle said:

@KLH0128 said:

When Jordan handed the police file to Laura when they were at that house on Oregon or wherever, she said "do you know anything about this" or something like that. Laura looked at it like a deer caught in the headlights and said no. Jordan had obviously read the file so if it was about Laura, she would have known. So it can't be the David Hamilton murder. And it can't be the Teresa Carter murder that was retconned several years ago. I know Laura told Scotty the report had been heavily redacted but it couldn't have been so heavily redacted that it wouldn't show the principle people's names.

I don't think it's the David Hamilton murder either because Laura's name would be in the file, since she confessed to it.

I think it could be the Theresa Carter case. If I remember the retcon right, Rick and Scotty buried her body. So if the body was never found, then it's a missing persons case. Or if it turns out that the body was eventually found, maybe it's a cold case file in homicide. Either way, I dont think Laura's name would be in that file. IIRC, no one knows she murdered Theresa except for Scott and later on, Luke.

How many people has Laura killed??

@cflr said:

@revelle said:

@KLH0128 said:

When Jordan handed the police file to Laura when they were at that house on Oregon or wherever, she said "do you know anything about this" or something like that. Laura looked at it like a deer caught in the headlights and said no. Jordan had obviously read the file so if it was about Laura, she would have known. So it can't be the David Hamilton murder. And it can't be the Teresa Carter murder that was retconned several years ago. I know Laura told Scotty the report had been heavily redacted but it couldn't have been so heavily redacted that it wouldn't show the principle people's names.

I don't think it's the David Hamilton murder either because Laura's name would be in the file, since she confessed to it.

I think it could be the Theresa Carter case. If I remember the retcon right, Rick and Scotty buried her body. So if the body was never found, then it's a missing persons case. Or if it turns out that the body was eventually found, maybe it's a cold case file in homicide. Either way, I dont think Laura's name would be in that file. IIRC, no one knows she murdered Theresa except for Scott and later on, Luke.

How many people has Laura killed??

4 if you count freezing Stavros. She also killed one of Frank Smith’s men.

Maybe Cyrus can reveal Rosalie's secret!!

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

Professor David Hamilton had two children and a wife who were killed in the wreckage of his home. David was left paralyzed. It’s possible Cyrus was one of the children and survived.

What??? I remember the David Hamilton storyline but I don't remember anything about him having a wife, 2 kids, a house collapse or him being paralyzed. What I remember is he was a friend of Rick Webber's, teenager Laura had a affair with him and then killed him by bashing him over the head with one of his own art sculptures. Lesley took the rap for it and went to prison for a while until Laura confessed.

That was his backstory. I don’t think any of his family was ever seen.

David was tried to seduce Lesley in revenge as David's late wife had apparently always been in love with Rick.

Also I thought Laura pushed David and he fell and hit his head on the hearth and died.

No, none of David's family was ever seen. I know that for sure. I had completely forgotten his backstory and even hearing it now, I don't remember it. But I'll take everybody's word for it. I'm almost certain Laura bashed him in the head with one of his own statues/sculptures. I can almost picture her doing that. Maybe somebody else here will remember?

Phil Brewer was killed when he was bludgeoned with a geode by Augusta McLeod. Are you thinking of that murder?

No, I'm not thinking of Phil and Augusta, although I do remember that. I'm picturing Laura bashing somebody over the head with their own statue/art sculpture. I could have sworn it was David but today's episode confirmed that I'm wrong. She did indeed push him and his head hit the hearth.

@KLH0128 said:

No, I'm not thinking of Phil and Augusta, although I do remember that. I'm picturing Laura bashing somebody over the head with their own statue/art sculpture. I could have sworn it was David but today's episode confirmed that I'm wrong. She did indeed push him and his head hit the hearth.

I don't remember the scene you're thinking of, but honestly, I am sure she did bash someone over the head with a statue. She was the show's original adventure girl. Laura carried a carpetbag so Sam could one day wear hooker boots.

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

Professor David Hamilton had two children and a wife who were killed in the wreckage of his home. David was left paralyzed. It’s possible Cyrus was one of the children and survived.

What??? I remember the David Hamilton storyline but I don't remember anything about him having a wife, 2 kids, a house collapse or him being paralyzed. What I remember is he was a friend of Rick Webber's, teenager Laura had a affair with him and then killed him by bashing him over the head with one of his own art sculptures. Lesley took the rap for it and went to prison for a while until Laura confessed.

That was his backstory. I don’t think any of his family was ever seen.

David was tried to seduce Lesley in revenge as David's late wife had apparently always been in love with Rick.

Also I thought Laura pushed David and he fell and hit his head on the hearth and died.

No, none of David's family was ever seen. I know that for sure. I had completely forgotten his backstory and even hearing it now, I don't remember it. But I'll take everybody's word for it. I'm almost certain Laura bashed him in the head with one of his own statues/sculptures. I can almost picture her doing that. Maybe somebody else here will remember?

Phil Brewer was killed when he was bludgeoned with a geode by Augusta McLeod. Are you thinking of that murder?

No, I'm not thinking of Phil and Augusta, although I do remember that. I'm picturing Laura bashing somebody over the head with their own statue/art sculpture. I could have sworn it was David but today's episode confirmed that I'm wrong. She did indeed push him and his head hit the hearth.

Is it possible you are thinking of David Grey?

The sword of Malkuth magically pushed him out a window, Defenestrated by Luke.

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

@KLH0128 said:

@Youcanmakeabettermovie said:

Professor David Hamilton had two children and a wife who were killed in the wreckage of his home. David was left paralyzed. It’s possible Cyrus was one of the children and survived.

What??? I remember the David Hamilton storyline but I don't remember anything about him having a wife, 2 kids, a house collapse or him being paralyzed. What I remember is he was a friend of Rick Webber's, teenager Laura had a affair with him and then killed him by bashing him over the head with one of his own art sculptures. Lesley took the rap for it and went to prison for a while until Laura confessed.

That was his backstory. I don’t think any of his family was ever seen.

David was tried to seduce Lesley in revenge as David's late wife had apparently always been in love with Rick.

Also I thought Laura pushed David and he fell and hit his head on the hearth and died.

No, none of David's family was ever seen. I know that for sure. I had completely forgotten his backstory and even hearing it now, I don't remember it. But I'll take everybody's word for it. I'm almost certain Laura bashed him in the head with one of his own statues/sculptures. I can almost picture her doing that. Maybe somebody else here will remember?

Phil Brewer was killed when he was bludgeoned with a geode by Augusta McLeod. Are you thinking of that murder?

No, I'm not thinking of Phil and Augusta, although I do remember that. I'm picturing Laura bashing somebody over the head with their own statue/art sculpture. I could have sworn it was David but today's episode confirmed that I'm wrong. She did indeed push him and his head hit the hearth.

Is it possible you are thinking of David Grey?