Season Regulars 3

1. 

   Kaitlyn Dever

   Marie Adler

2. 

   Toni Collette

   Detective Grace Rasmussen

3. 

   Merritt Wever

   Detective Karen Duvall

Guest Stars 36

1. 

   Elizabeth Marvel

   Judith

2. Patricia Fa'asua

   Becca

3. 

   Aaron Staton

   Curtis McCarthy

4. 

   Eric Lange

   Detective Robert Parker

5. 

   Bill Fagerbakke

   Detective Pruitt

6. 

   Dale Dickey

   RoseMarie

7. 

   Blake Ellis

   Chris McCarthy

8. 

   Graham Hamilton

   James Massey

9. 

   Melissa Bailey

   DMV Lady

10. 

    Elena Campbell-Martinez

    Judge Audrey Costas

11. 

    Christopher Chen

    DMV Tester

12. 

    Devin Crittenden

    Wasted Preppy Guy

13. Trevor Lee Georgeson

    Bartender

14. 

    Rueben Grundy

    Sergeant Zellner

15. Eric Henry

    Cashier

16. 

    Alison Jaye Horowitz

    Nicole

17. 

    Victoria Garcia-Kelleher

    Soccer Mom

18. Dejon LaQuake

    Ryan

19. 

    Kya Kruse

    Nadia

20. Jeff Marchelletta

    WM Police Chief

21. 

    Ashton Moio

    Wasted Trust Fund Guy

22. 

    Veronica St. Clair

    Girlfriend

23. 

    Fay Wolf

    Receptionist

24. Reginald M. Jernigan Jr.

    Lakewood Uni Cop (uncredited)

25. 

    Omar Ghonim

    FBI Tech

26. 

    Max Arciniega

    Jason Alvarez

27. 

    Scott Lawrence

    Special Agent Billy Taggart

28. 

    Jun Hee Lee

    Officer Geoffrey Morris

29. 

    Tim Martin Gleason

    Bennett

30. 

    Connor Tillman

    Officer Nick Selig

31. 

    John Hartmann

    Donald Hughes

32. 

    Annaleigh Ashford

    Lilly Darrow

33. Aiden Randall

    Ricardo

34. 

    Omar Maskati

    Elias

35. 

    Kai Lennox

    Steve Rasmussen

36. 

    Liza Lapira

    Mia

Crew 15