吉勒摩·戴托羅之珍奇櫃についてのディスカッション

It has been a long (long, long, long!) time since I've watched something that was so well crafted, deep and intellectually/culturally challenging. Art is not dead! Wow. Just profound. I almost bailed on this series, but this one will having me see them through to the end. And--shocker of shockers--I've been rating each episode and this is by far--BY FAR-- the best so far. I say "shocker of shockers" because when I went to rate it it is rated so much lower than the other ones (and I rated them lower than they had been rated by others). I don't get it. This is a 10++ for me. Simply a stunning and honest consideration of our tendencies!

Did anyone else think so? For the low ratings: why? I'm OK with it, but it truly don't get it! Great stuff!!

2 replies (on page 1 of 1)

Jump to last post

@NeoLosman said:

Did anyone else think so? For the low ratings: why? I'm OK with it, but it truly don't get it! Great stuff!!

Del Torro rammed a machete through his own jugular in the first episode, the writing for which is a masterclass in saturating your script with as many Woke shibboleths as possible; Tim Blake Nelson's character is practically a Saturday morning cartoon version of what a racist looks like. This isn't true of all the episodes by any means, nonetheless Ep 1 left many viewers with a woeful first impression. This is reflected in the low ratings the series has received overall

I don't know that I payed enough attention to the first couple of episodes to know why they were bad, but you could very well be right. Sadly, the lack of artfulness in art has become the standard rather than the exception. Perhaps it has always been that way, but all I do know is I thought this episode was amazing.

As to the ratings, the reason I asked was not because of the overall series ratings, but rather my own per episode ratings seem to run contrary to other's ratings. (I'm sure you know this, but you can see individual episode ratings by clicking on "Season 1" and expanding each episode. I haven't even rated the series yet.

Yes, so it is cyclical it seems. Or the oscillation of a pendulum. No matter, I'm glad to see some light breaking through!

映画やテレビ番組が見つかりませんか?ログインして作成してください。

全般

s 検索バーに移動する
p プロファイルメニューを開く
esc 開いているウィンドウを閉じる
? キーボードショートカットウィンドウを開く

メディアのページ

b 戻る(または該当する場合は親に)
e 編集ページに行く

テレビ番組のシーズンのページ

(右矢印)次のシーズンに行く
(左矢印)前のシーズンに戻る

テレビ番組のエピソードのページ

(右矢印)次のエピソードに進む
(左矢印)前のエピソードに戻る

全ての画像のページ

a 画像追加ウィンドウを開く

全ての編集ページ

t 翻訳選択を開く
ctrl+ s フォームを送信する

ディスカッションのページ

n 新しいディスカッションを作成する
w 監視ステータスを切り替える
p 公開/非公開を切り替える
c 閉じる/開くを切り替える
a アクティビティを開く
r ディスカッションに返信
l 最後の返事に行く
ctrl+ enter メッセージを送信する
(右矢印)次のページ
(左矢印)前のページ

設定

このアイテムを評価したり、リストに追加したりしたいですか?

ログイン

メンバーではありませんか?

登録してコミュニティに参加