Lainey is blij dat ze terug aan de slag kan, maar Mellor waarschuwt haar dat ze te vriendschappelijk omgaat met haar studenten. Glascott stelt de nieuwe lerares wetenschappen voor. C.B. heeft bedenkingen bij haar manier van aanpakken.

Lainey is hoopvol voor het liefdesleven van coach Mellor. Glascott weet niet goed hoe hij met bibliothecaresse dr. Ness moet omgaan.

Na het zien van de film 'Rudy' wil een van de leerlingen van C.B. een footballspeler worden. Glascott maant Lainey aan om een vriendin te vinden bij wie ze haar hart kan luchten en bij wie ze kan aankloppen voor levensadvies. Lainey probeert daarop vriendschap te sluiten met Wilma.

In de hoop een grotere kans te maken op de titel, rekruteren coach Mellor en Glascott sterspeler Felicia voor het team. C.B. gaat mee als begeleider op een shortski. Stiekem hoopt hij er wat qualitytime met Lainey te kunnen doorbrengen.

Wanneer coach Mellor vlak voor het toernooi ziek wordt, moet Glascott zijn taken als trainer overnemen. Lainey volgt les bij C.B.

Coach Mellor kijkt uit naar Halloween, maar Glascott dreigt roet in het eten te gooien van zijn plannen met Julie. C.B. probeert ervoor te zorgen dat de leerlingen elkaar niet de stuipen op het lijf jagen tijdens de halloweenoptocht.

CB celebrates Thanksgiving by having all of William Penn rally around him after a cooking incident at his house, while the alumni faculty football game brings out the competitive sides of Wilma and Coach Mellor.

Learning he’s not into baseball cards, Coach Mellor encourages Toby to be competitive in CB’s Pokemon Club and becomes an overbearing sports-type father. Meanwhile, Lainey supplements her salary as a teacher by working at the local video store and learns an important lesson.

CB hopes getting Lainey a Beanie Baby for Christmas will show his true feelings for her, but it doesn’t go as planned. Meanwhile, Principal Glascott tries to convince Felicia that she needs to participate and sing a song in a Kwanza play he has written for the students.

Wilma encourages Ronnie to pursue his dreams of being in a boy band but goes too far when a music video gets out for all of William Penn to see. Meanwhile, the school hires Aunt Julie as the new school nurse which quickly affects her relationship with Coach Mellor.

Principal Glascott and Lainey struggle to agree on what is an appropriate dress code, while Coach Mellor struggles with his relationship with Julie as she does not enjoy sports like he does.

The hit film has love on everyone's brain, and Lainey has a realization about CB. Meanwhile, Principal Glascott uses the season's bad football team to teach Coach Mellor how to be both a good winner and a good loser.

In honor of Valentine's Day, Principal Glascott throws a "dating game" based on the show "Singled Out" where Lainey uses the opportunity to figure out her feelings. Meanwhile, Felicia is having body-image issues and Coach Mellor throws a workout camp to help her self-esteem.

Wilma steps in to help CB move on from Lainey with help from Coach Mellor, while Lainey learns she has unresolved issues from her past when mentoring a student.

While preparing students for the school's show choir, Lainey realizes Wilma might be a better singer than her and gets competitive. Meanwhile, Coach Mellor and Aunt Julie fight over how to parent Toby.

Cool parent Greg distracts CB from being a good teacher to help his son Weasel receive extra credit, while former Principal Ball is upset at Principal Glascott when he approves the use of Ball's parking spot as a community garden.

Lainey is reunited with her mother; Wilma adds something to the robotics club.

Coach Mellor deals with jealousy issues after learning Julie is friends with a handsome doctor. Meanwhile, Glascott appoints CB to be substitute principal after his surgery, but needs Lainey to solve a problem with the mean girls of William Penn that he can't.

Smitten with environmental consultant Paloma, who was hired to oversee William Penn's Earth Day activities, CB's feelings may change when he learns she wants to stop an important construction project at the school. Meanwhile, Wilma gets a surprise after convincing Lainey that yearbook superlatives are not important.

Lainey has a difficult choice regarding her relationship with Barry and her friendship with CB. Meanwhile, Coach Mellor is put in a tough parenting position when Toby is invited to prom as a freshman by a senior.