Дискутиране на Стар Трек: Дискавъри

... Excerpt from Star Trek: Discovery Never Worked And It’s Because Of One Key Reason:


Recently, enterprising fans received the surprise news that the Paramount+ flagship show Star Trek: Discovery would be ending with its upcoming fifth season. This was not originally conceived as a final season for the show, meaning that the actors had to come back and shoot additional scenes to wrap things up, and actors and fans alike found themselves asking why this flagship show was getting unceremoniously canceled like this. But here’s a truth even blunter than Michael Burnham’s “Vulcan hello” … Star Trek: Discovery never fully worked because it never fully embraced the core ideas that made Star Trek resonate with so many fans from The Original Series to The Next Generation and beyond.



... Excerpt from Star Trek: Discovery Never Quite Worked – Because It Rejected Core Star Trek Ideas:


So, ultimately, the central error of "Discovery," and the reason many Trekkies didn't connect with it, is that it attempted to eliminate trekking from its own formula. In so doing, it eliminated a variety of missions. It eliminated a need to establish protocol and a group dynamic among the crew. It eliminated the need for diplomacy. There were no ethical dilemmas to work through. It was all violence and sadness. And while violence and sadness have their place in "Star Trek," it shouldn't have been its basis.

I would, however, be remiss if I didn't state some of the things "Discovery" did amazingly right. In terms of representation and depicting a utopian crew of varied humanity, "Discovery" was first-rate. In addition to featuring a Black woman in the lead, there are no less than four openly queer characters. Dr. Culber (Wilson Cruz) and Lt. Stamets (Anthony Rapp) are happily married, and have adopted a non-binary child named Adira (Blu Del Barrio) who is, in turn, in love with a young man named Gray played a trans/masc actor (Ian Alexander) who uses they/them pronouns. Trek wasn't always great about queer representation. Here, they are happy to be open about it. This was done 100% right.



... Comment from Reddit:


Hilarious/tragic now it's ending people are finally free to talk what they really thought about it.

Half the star trek subs and media outlets were calling people all kinds of names for not liking it

3 отговора (на страница 1 от общо 1)

Jump to last post

@wonder2wonder said:



... Excerpt from Star Trek: Discovery Never Quite Worked – Because It Rejected Core Star Trek Ideas:

I would, however, be remiss if I didn't state some of the things "Discovery" did amazingly right. In terms of representation and depicting a utopian crew of varied humanity, "Discovery" was first-rate. In addition to featuring a Black woman in the lead, there are no less than four openly queer characters. Dr. Culber (Wilson Cruz) and Lt. Stamets (Anthony Rapp) are happily married, and have adopted a non-binary child named Adira (Blu Del Barrio) who is, in turn, in love with a young man named Gray played a trans/masc actor (Ian Alexander) who uses they/them pronouns. Trek wasn't always great about queer representation. Here, they are happy to be open about it. This was done 100% right.

I always figured they would have developed cures by the 23rd century. Which would explain why TOS never mentioned it.

Maybe because nobody is watching it and CBS/Paramounts needs to mind it's finances

I was very, very unhappy with Season 1. I quit the show completely. After giving SNW a try and mostly liking it, I decided to just force myself to watch Discovery in the hopes that maybe I would like it now.

I don't. It's still largely a badly written show with shallow superficial characters, though I can say season 2 was better than season 1 and season 3 actually had some really entertaining moments here and there, but season 4 is a slog and almost as bad as season 1. It's not a good show by any means and feels much closer to fan fiction Star Wars than Star Trek. There is almost nothing about this show that feels like Star Trek to me.

But it really just comes down to bad writing. It has lots of women, lots of non-whites and lots of rainbow people, but they are lacking good writing to make me care about any of them.

Не можете да откриете филм или сериал? Влезте, за да го създадете.

Глобални

s фокусиране на лентата за търсене
p отваряне на меню "Профил"
esc затваряне на отворен прозорец
? отваряне на прозореца за клавишните комбинации

На страниците за медиите

b връщане назад
e към страницата за редактиране

На страниците за сезони

(стрелка надясно) към следващ сезон
(стрелка наляво) към предишния сезон

На страниците за епизоди

(стрелка надясно) към следващ епизод
(стрелка наляво) предишен епизод

На всички страници за изображения

a отваряне на прозорец за добавяне на изображение

На всички страници за редактиране

t меню за избор на език, на превода
ctrl+ s изпращане на форма

На страниците за дискусия

n създаване на нова дискусия
w статус на наблюдаване
p публична/лична
c затваряне/отваряне
a отваряне на действия
r отговаряне в дискусия
l към последния отговор
ctrl+ enter изпращане на вашето съобщение
(стрелка надясно) следваща страница
(стрелка наляво) предишна страница

Настройки

Искате ли да го оцените или добавите към списък?

Вход