Maddie, okulda alkol ile yakalanınca okuldan atılmak ile rehabilitasyon arasında bir tercih yapmak zorunda bırakılacaktır.

Maddie, aynı anda yaşadığı iki farklı hayatı düzene sokmaya çalışırken arkadaşlarına bir şey yansıtmamaya çalışmaktadır.

Maddie kaldığı eve ve yeni hayatına ayak uydurmuşken arkadaşının doğum günü için düzenleyeceği parti onun için büyük bir sınav olacaktır.

Trish kızını geri alabilmek için çalışmaya başlar. Wes ve Maddie unutamayacakları bir gün geçirecektir. Bu sırada Wes'in aile sorunları açığa çıkar.

Trish is panicking upon the discovery that her mom has disappeared with her daughter, compelling Maddie to take a drastic step to calm her.

Ellie’s suspicions about Maddie’s recent behavior grow, leading her to discover where Maddie is now spending her time. Charlotte presses Wes for more information on Maddie’s progress, leading Wes to suggest that Charlotte might need some help herself. Several relationships take surprising turns, and Wes, Vern, and Craig spend an afternoon bonding. Flashbacks show how Maddie and Ellie came to be friends, and Ellie’s own tragic experiences with addiction.

While reluctantly attending a party thrown by Rebecca’s upper crust family, Maddie and Charlotte are horrified at Rebecca’s treatment by her family in regards to her recovery. Wes is thrown when his ex-girlfriend Harper returns and claims she’s now clean. He is further rocked when Harper drops a bombshell regarding his brother. In light of recent events, Cynthia is forced to re-examine her relationship with her fiancé. Flashbacks show how Charlotte realized her daughter had a problem with alcohol and decided to turn her in to Cynthia.

Emma’s mom, Angela, returns wanting to make amends with Ben and build a relationship with Emma, but Ben is distrustful of her motives.

Maddie is devastated when she finds out Charlotte is the one that turned her in. Wes comes clean about a secret he’s been holding, but it backfires on him, and Cynthia makes a confession.