I was VERY upset. They were far and away my favorites -- hard-working, gutsy and funny wife and nice, supportive husband. They built a kick-ass shelter and seemed to be enjoying themselves. Very upset. But, no amount of money is worth endangering your life, and Brooke seemed like she was getting dangerously thin.

Agree with your last sentence.

I binge watched the whole series and they said during survivor school that one disadvantage they had as a team is that she came in so thin. Unfortunately she didn't have much to lose.