Lilly is ecstatic when she gets two tickets to a Hannah Montana concert and invites Miley to accompany her. Miley refuses, saying that she doesn't like Hannah Montana. Miley's dad, Robby, tries to convince her to tell Lilly her secret: That she is Hannah Montana. When Lilly finds out what Miley's been hiding, will she treat her the same? Jackson won't take no for an answer when he wants to borrow money for his big date. But his dad keeps refusing to be his personal ATM.

Miley, Lilly, and Oliver are just itching to get revenge on bratty Amber & Ashley during a class camping trip, even though Robbie told Miley not to sink to their level. When Miley and her friends give the girls their comeuppance, she thinks that they got away with it, but she finds herself with a whole new itch to scratch as Hannah Montana. Meanwhile, Jackson and Robbie try to rid themselves of a mouse with a surprising talent.

Miley declines Jake's invitation to the school dance. While Hannah is filming a guest spot on Jake's show, she learns that Jake has feelings for a girl named Miley. She changes her mind about his dance invite, but Miley finds out that he has asked Lilly instead. Jackson and Robby decide to see who's the better prankster by pulling practical jokes on one another.

Oliver believes that the key to getting Lilly and Miley's friendship back on track is by handcuffing the girls together. Unfortunately, his plan backfires and he may lose his friendship with both girls if he can't find where he put the handcuff keys. Robby discovers that silence really is golden when he wants his son to pay attention to him.

In an auction hosted by Donny Osmond, Hannah is up for bid in a special "Date with Hannah Montana" prize. Ray Romano makes an appearance at the auction, although Hannah doesn't know who he is. After a bidding war between Hannah's crush Johnny Collins and Rico, she has to take both on the date together.

Miley agrees to go out with a charming boy named Connor for the holidays. Connor's elfin stature and his job helping Santa at the mall, however, clashes with her idea of the perfect guy. The neighborhood Scrooge, Mr. Dontzig, offers to get Jackson into the college of his dreams, but only if Jackson and Robby do everything that he asks of them.

Hannah is on a talk show and says she doesn't like carrots and books and her fans have no choice but to do likewise.

Miley experiences nothing but bad luck on the SS Tipton after she loses an ankle bracelet her mom gave her. Miley believes the missing jewelry is a good-luck charm and is desperate to get it back. At home, Jackson opens a large package after Robby forbids him to do so, and he suffers the consequences.

The crossover starts on Wizards of Waverly Place S2E25 Cast-Away (To Another Show) (I) and The Suite Life on Deck S1E21 Double-Crossed (II).

Miley starts to miss her old life in Tennessee. Oliver gets an offer to go on a concert tour, but his joy is dampened when realizes that he won't be able to see Lilly for six months. Jackson decides that it is time for him to leave home.

Jackson makes himself at home in his new bachelor pad but quickly finds out that the place is a crumbling wreck. Miley mulls over the idea of going back to the simple life in Tennessee. Oliver contemplates giving up the tour to be with Lilly, while Lilly tries to figure out what she will do without Oliver and Miley in her life.

Miley is forced to make an unwanted trip down memory lane after Robby has her room redecorated. Jackson becomes a believer in the golden rule once he lays eyes on his new neighbor.

Miley gets a movie deal that will take a year away from her, making her incapable of going to college with her best friend. She keeps this from Lilly and tries to get Lilly to come to the decision of not wanting to go to college with Miley. Rico finds Jackson a dream job, and Rico and Jackson finally reveal that while they may fight, they are also close friends.