Finch and Elliot are fighting over Amy. Jack warns Amy that the fight is interfering with the office work environment, and so Finch and Elliot come to terms about Amy: they decide that since they both like her so much, they should share her, meaning she would spend half her time with one and then the other half with the other. Of course Amy is not ok with that and decides to quit the magazine altogether since she got a six figure book deal. Meanwhile, Jack and Nina try hard to show Kevin the good of being rich and end up corrupting him. Now Kevin, who was once happy and simple, is miserable and full of debts.

Amy decide programar una cita por separado con Finch y Elliott. Jack insiste en pedirle que elija entre uno de los dos. Sin embargo, Finch y Elliott, al darse cuenta de la situación, logran alcanzar un acuerdo y quedan para salir los tres juntos.