Diskutuj o Scrubs

Item: My Finale (2) (8x19)

Language: en-US

Type of Problem: Incorrect_content

Extra Details: S08E18/19 were aired as a double episode, so as such I believe that they should be merged into S08E18 and S08E19 be deleted. They were only split into two later when the DVD was released.

6 odpoveďí (na strane 1 z 1)

Jump to last post

I'm not getting anywhere with the ABC archives. Do you have proof it was originally broadcast as one episode, not two?

All newspapers on newspapers.com show the same thing, it airing as a double episode: https://i.imgur.com/4eNX9aF.png

i would like this to be reviewed as 2 episodes, if you define episodes as things that have an intro/opening sequence and credits, then this show aired as 2 episodes on the same night back to back.

if you watch the episode, there is a "to be continued" on screen followed by outtakes as the credits roll.

the next episode opens with JD saying "previously on".

Wikipedia/IMDb lists it as 2 episodes, it has 2 production codes, its on dvd as 2 separate episodes. my question would be, why would they intentionally split them up if they originally made as 1 episode, just for the dvd release?.

it's also currently on sbs Australia on demand as 2 episodes. opensubtiles has it separate too.

https://www.sbs.com.au/ondemand/tv-series/scrubs/season-8

@stevene said:

if you define episodes as things that have an intro/opening sequence and credits, then this show aired as 2 episodes on the same night back to back.

An episode is the entity advertised by the broadcaster at the time of the original broadcast.

As you can see in the newspapers snippets provided by @Sheigutn , you will see that this episode was advertised at one single element.

it has 2 production codes, its on dvd as 2 separate episodes. my question would be, why would they intentionally split them up if they originally made as 1 episode, just for the dvd release?.

As indicated by the 2 production codes, it was produced as 2 separate episodes, but as indicated by the newspapers snippets, it has been originally broadcasted as a single one.

The fact that it is now streamed and released on DVD as 2 episodes has no impact on our listing, which should be based on the original broadcast.

I also quote the Scrubs fandom : "The episode was split in two parts on DVD, ABC.com, Hulu, Netflix and syndicated reruns, but aired as an hour long single episode when it originally aired on ABC."

@superboy97 said:

An episode is the entity advertised by the broadcaster at the time of the original broadcast.

you can see my point though... even watching it as broadcast, it plays like 2 seperate episodes.

and you might want to add that to a FAQ somewhere.

Nemôžeš nájsť film alebo seriál? Prihlás sa a pridaj ho.

Globálne

s zamerať sa na vyhľadávací riadok
p otvoriť menu profilu
esc zatvoriť otvorené okno
? otvoriť okno klávesových skratiek

Na média stránkach

b ísť späť (do rodičovského pokiaľ možno)
e íst na stránku úprav

Na stránkach seriálových serií

(pravá šípka) ísť na nasledujúcu sériu
(ľavá šípka) ísť na predchádzajúcu sériu

Na stránkach seriálových epizód

(pravá šípka) ísť na nasledujúcu epizódu
(ľavá šipka) isť na predchádzajúcu epizódu

Na všetkých obrázkových strankach

a otvoriť okno pre pridanie obrázku

Na všetkých stránkach úprav

t otvoriť výber prekladu
ctrl+ s odoslať formulár

Na stránkach diskusií

n vytvoriť novú diskusiu
w prepínač stavu pozerania
p prepínač verejný/súkromný
c prepínač zatvorený/otvorený
a otvoriť aktivitu
r odpovedať v diskusií
l ísť na poslednú odpoveď
ctrl+ enter odoslať vašu správu
(pravá šípka) nasledujúca strana
(ľavá šípka) predchádzajúca strana

Nastavenia

Chcete ohodnotiť alebo pridať túto položku do zoznamu?

Prihlásiť sa