Rei es una oficinista que juega a un juego para chicas, aunque ella juega porque adora el personaje de la villana. Un día al despertar descubre que se ha reencarnado dentro del juego como rival de la villana.

En su afán por pasar más tiempo al lado de Claire, Rae se presenta como candidata para convertirse en su sirvienta y consigue el trabajo, pese a las negativas de Claire.

Rae se da cuenta de que ha caído en la ruta del juego de Rob e intenta salirse de ella para poder pasar más tiempo con Claire y ayudarla en su relación con Thane.

Rae y Claire asisten a clase de magia donde les van a enseñar cómo utilizar los diferentes elementos. Sin embargo, un monstruo irrumpe en mitad de la clase y se ven obligadas a luchar.

Rae and Claire both pass the written exam for entry into the Academy Knights. The next step is the practical exam, which pits the examinees against each other in mock battles to determine who is truly worthy to join the Knights.

The Foundation Day Fair is coming up, and the Academy Knights discuss what sort of shop they should open. An offhanded comment by Rae leads to the proposal of a cross-dressing café.

Rae makes the most of the Foundation Day Fair, working hard at the cross-dressing café and even convincing Claire to walk around the fair with her. But an incident with a group of bitter commoners casts a shadow over the festive atmosphere...

The Royal Academy is rocked by scandal when a noble student allegedly attacks a commoner student with magic. The situation escalates when the attacker receives minimal punishment, spurring commoners to protest so violently that the school must be closed.

As a darker plot is revealed behind the commoner uprising, the academy is plunged into peril. Can Rae and Claire defeat the conspirators and deal with the resulting aftermath?

Princess Manaria of the Sousse Kingdom, an old childhood friend of Claire's, shows up to visit her. Manaria has it all—good looks, charisma, tremendous magic proficiency—and to top it off, Claire is quite taken with her. It seems Rae has a new rival...

Rae insists she just wants Claire to be happy, even if she can't be with her. Manaria tells her she's just running away, and if her feelings for Claire are true, she'll fight for her. So begins their duel to determine who will stay by Claire's side...

Manaria challenges Rae to prove her feelings for Claire at the Amour Ceremony. Both Rae and Manaria must place an item on the Scales of Love, which will measure the weight of their feelings for Claire. Who will the scales find worthy?