Discuter de Star Trek: Voyager
Discuter → Émissions télévisées → Star Trek: Voyager → Générales
S4E07: "Scientific Method"
posté par wonder2wonderSTAFFMOD le 23 janvier 2020 à 02h57
The crew discover that aliens are experimenting on them.
There is an interesting conversation between Janeway and one of the aliens.
Alzen: "Please understand that there's a purpose to our actions. The data we gather from you may help us cure physical and psychological disorders that afflict millions. Isn't that worth some discomfort?"
Janeway: "I'm sure you'd see things differently, if your people were the ones being subjected to these experiments."
Alzen: "Just as your perspective would change if your people were the ones to live longer and healthier lives as a result. Don't forget, we've been observing you, Captain. I know the most important thing to you is the welfare of your crew. You'd even kill to protect them."
...
Janeway: "What you're doing isn't self-defence. It's the exploitation of another species for your own benefit. My people decided a long time ago that that was unacceptable, even in the name of scientific progress."
...
Janeway: "Sorry. These lab rats are fighting back."
It's good to know that one day in the future, humans of Earth will no longer exploit other species.
Does she mean sentient, intelligent species? Or all species?
Réponse de Nexus71
le 26 janvier 2020 à 18h35
I think she meant sentient intelligent species .Neelix still prepares animals for food(He makes a crab dish for 7)
Réponse de Knixon
le 30 mars 2022 à 15h14
Does it count if it's just replicated? I don't think they were carrying any food animals on Voyager.
Réponse de VobIdem
le 2 avril 2022 à 15h20
Everyone except Mark I EMHs
Réponse de Knixon
le 2 avril 2022 à 15h56
Holograms are not a species.
Réponse de VobIdem
le 17 avril 2022 à 08h27
Sounds like someone has either never seen Star Trek Voyager or is a Holo-ist
Réponse de Knixon
le 17 avril 2022 à 16h52
I've seen it, but they haven't fooled me.
Réponse de Nexus71
le 8 mai 2022 à 06h58
Knix also thinks androids are not a species that's why he hates Picard .😁
Réponse de Knixon
le 9 mai 2022 à 22h42
Not just not a species, they're not a sentient life form. Because they are neither alive, nor sentient.
Réponse de Nexus71
le 18 mai 2022 à 03h39
Plus they make for a cheap and lousy plot device for which the "writers" of Secret Hideout and Kurtzman in particular seem to have a hard on .Just like future alien A.I. wanting to destroy all biological life in the galaxy and mirror universes(although they don't have a clue how these alternate realities really work )