Item: QI
Language: en-US
Type of Problem: Incorrect_content
Extra Details: Wrong episode numbering for "Season 18" (aka "Series R"). For some reason the real E13 has been placed as E16 here on themoviedb. This has also "pushed" the real E14-16 to be wrongly numbered. The correct episode numbers should be: "R Animals" E13 "Rogue" E14 "Random" E15 "Rock 'n' Roll" E16
This can be verified on BBC's own QI page:https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000tq9x
regards
Nie możesz znaleźć filmu lub serialu? Zaloguj się, aby go utworzyć.
Want to rate or add this item to a list?
Not a member?
Odpowiedź użytkownika superboy97
1 października 2023 o godz. 9:02AM
Even if "R Animals" was produced to be episode 13, it was only broadcasted in March 2021 after the other 3 episodes which were broadcasted in January 2021.
Odpowiedź użytkownika woodfighter
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 12:32PM
No. "R Animals" was broadcast on 2021-01-07, in march they showed a shorter alternative version of the same episode but to quote yourself: "TMDB doesn't support alternate versions."
Odpowiedź użytkownika superboy97
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 12:58PM
On January 7, 2021, the episode broadcasted was the XL version of this episode. The regular version of it was only broadcasted in March.
Reminder : The alternate version of this show is the XL version, even if for one or two episodes, their XL version has been broadcasted first.
Odpowiedź użytkownika woodfighter
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 1:22PM
Either QI XL is an alternative show or the first airing of the episode was on 2021-01-07 and the rules clearly state "Episodes should be added exactly as they first aired on the original network (title, date, order, season). "
Odpowiedź użytkownika superboy97
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 1:26PM
"QI XL" is an alternative show that shouldn't be listed, and the episode broadcasted on January 7, 2021 is part of this "QI XL" show and, consequently, shouldn't be listed.
The regular episode of the "QI" show was only broadcasted in March.
Odpowiedź użytkownika woodfighter
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 1:44PM
The version broadcast in march is a re-edit of the first run of the episode. I don't see how the rules would make an exception here. If we follow your argument that QI XL is a different show (as the network does) than I don't see why it shouldn't be listed.
Odpowiedź użytkownika superboy97
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 1:47PM
As already indicated, "QI XL" is an alternate version of the "QI" show. As per our rules, this show shouldn't be listed. Only the episodes of the regular "QI" show should be listed (even in the few cases were the "QI XL" version has been broadcasted first).
Odpowiedź użytkownika woodfighter
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 1:57PM
Says who? And where do the rules talk about alternative shows I can only find information on alternative episodes?
Odpowiedź użytkownika superboy97
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 1:59PM
This was already explained in this 2021 previous content report.
This appears in the rule in the "Not Supported" part of it. I quote : "Alternative versions, including 3D/IMAX, director's cut, extended versions, dubbed versions, remastered versions, commentary (e.g. RiffTrax), fan events and special screenings."
Odpowiedź użytkownika woodfighter
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 2:09PM
No it wasn't. How is it decided which version is the alternative? According to the rules it should be the first one broadcast that counts. How could the XL version be an extended version of something that hadn't aired yet?
Aditionally the airdate for the episode "All I Want For Christmas Is U" is wrong or the series switched network to the BBC iPlayer, because only the XL version aired that day on BBC2: https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/guide/bbctwo/20231218
Odpowiedź użytkownika superboy97
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 2:20PM
Yes, this is the first one. The "QI" show has started before "QI XL". So, the original is the "QI" show, not the "QI XL". In this case, the decision is taken at the show level.
Please, file a separate content report. This is not related to season 18.
Odpowiedź użytkownika woodfighter
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 2:31PM
Who makes that decision? What if the BBC decides to only air the XL episodes in the future, will the show be declared canceled by TMDB?
I won't, I only stated that to show the absurdity of your interpretation of a too rigid ruleset.
Odpowiedź użytkownika superboy97
22 grudnia 2023 o godz. 2:35PM
The team of moderators.
In this case, the situation will be analysed and a decision will be taken by the team of moderators.