Shawn descubre un cadáver en la masión del consulado británico mientras investiga la desaparición de una figuritas de Star Wars perdidas. Para poner a la policía tras la pista del caso, afirma haber tendido una visión del asesinato, poniendo su reputación como vidente en el punto de mira.

Después de una noche de fiesta, Shawn, Gus, Woody y Lassiter se despiertan en la oficina de Psych. Sin recuerdos de lo ocurrido la noche anterior y con varias pistas que les señalan como sospechosos de un asesinato. Desgraciadamente, dependerán de los poderes videntes de Shawn para esclarecer lo ocurrido.

Una hermosa mujer se aproxima a Lassiter y muestra cierto interés por él., para después desaparecer misteriosamente. MIentras Shawn y Gus investigan una serie de asesinatos en los que el culpable parece ser un vampiro.

La Mantis, un vigilante enmascarado, compite con el departamento de policía para atrapar a una banda de narcotraficantes, por lo que Shawn y Gus son contratados para intentar atrapar a este misterioso vigilante.

When the hitting coach of the Santa Barbara Seabirds suddenly dies, the team's manager hires Shawn and Gus to go undercover as the new coach and mascot in order to investigate.

After a billionaire murderer pleas insanity at his trial, Shawn and Gus go undercover at a mental hospital in order to prove that the man is, in fact, sane. While at the hospital, Shawn and Gus receive some hostility from one of the nurses.

Juliet's con-man father travels to Santa Barbara to reunite with his daughter, but finds himself slipping back into his criminal past when confronted with a dream con.

After a woman tells the SBPD she witnessed a murder happen in broad daylight, Shawn and Gus are the only ones who believe her, and therefore protect her by hiding her at a remote commune called Box Canyon Ranch, a place whose inhabitants label themselves as progressive intellectuals.

Shawn and Juliet's romantic getaway vacation to a spa gets interrupted by robberies and a dead body at a nearby winery.

Shawn and Gus team up with Despereaux to locate a mythical dagger rumored to be the key to unlocking a dead billionaire's treasure.

Lassiter hires Shawn and Gus to get to the bottom of strange occurrences at his new condo.

When the founder of "Right Now", Santa Barbara's oldest at-risk youth program, is shot and almost killed, Shawn, Gus and a few members of Gus's a capella group from college investigate to find the culprit.

The race is on to clear Woody's name and reputation when a mere mortician finds a mistake in the coroner's autopsy.

A wrongly convicted Southern chef hires Shawn and Gus to find the real thief after the Innocence Project frees him from prison.

A body relating to a 20-year-old case is finally found, and Shawn, Gus, and Henry revisit all the old suspects in order to solve the case