Discuss American Horror Story
Discuss → TV Shows → American Horror Story → General
Any predictions for what the plot twist will be?
posted by mountaingirlSTAFFMOD on September 20, 2017 at 4:01 PM
So I guess its pretty obvious at this point that the therapist is in the cult? He's giving the cult people the targets of people with phobias so I'm wondering what the big twist will be..That Ivy has been part of the cult all along and she's trying to get Ally to overcome her fears by making her face them? Lets hear your predictions! :-)
Reply by Melanie
on September 20, 2017 at 8:18 PM
Love your theory!!! I at first was thinking he was putting them through some experiment for fears but like your idea
Reply by Melanie
on September 20, 2017 at 9:42 PM
Ok after watching episode 3 the therapist is def involved but maybe even peters is the leader
Reply by komrad
on September 22, 2017 at 12:38 AM
Remember when that Gay dude said to Evan Peters that he wished his wife was dead. Yeah, Evan Peters made it happen. He's deffo the cult leader
Reply by Mrs. Y
on September 22, 2017 at 10:01 PM
I am starting to think both Evan Peters and his sister (Winter) are the leaders of the cult. Also, guessing the election was a coin toss and the "horror" to follow was determined by Pres Trump/Evan Peters Vs. Hillary/Winter. Winner's choice.
The things I wonder about: Is the therapist running his own game - yet in cahoots with Evan/Winter? The original couple killed - patients of the therapist? Does the therapist order a fetish kill once his patient is "cured"?
Reply by Oldnewbie
on September 22, 2017 at 11:04 PM
Kai and Winter could be the leaders with everyone, the therapist, the cop, all working with them as part of the "Cult" otherwise why call the season "Cult"? Even the protestors seemed to be under Kai's command as they vanished when he appeared among them. The neighbors also are part of it, but now that Meadow is dead\missing, the hubby is no longer on board. Or maybe he is as he is accusing Ally of the crime. All of this seems to be aimed at Ally and Ivy. Kai must have some grudge against them (aside form their sexuality).
Best ep of the season so far. Genuinely scary in places.
Reply by Pitt78
on September 23, 2017 at 12:49 PM
The twist will be Sarah Paulson's character will end up becoming a Trump supporter( seriously, this is Ryan Murphy we're talking about.) because with each episode she's losing her liberal status and becoming the target of the left. The members of the cult are fodder as the show's pretty heavy handed with who possible members are.
EDIT: Forgot to add that she'll also likely denounce her homosexuality because in Murphy's world Trump supporters, conservatives, can't be gay.
Reply by Oldnewbie
on September 23, 2017 at 3:45 PM
That maybe Kai's plan! Or one of them anyway. To take a person who is a text book definition of liberal and turn them into a conservative! Using her mental instability as a weapon against her was to weaken her. Then the protestors and the neighbors come along to portray liberals at their worst. So that may be Kai's game and the twist being Ally, if not Ivy, becoming the very thing they have always hated.
And just when is Evan gonna be nominated for an Emmy? I surely thought "Hotel" was his year as he completely embodied that character to the point I did not know it was him till I read it was him!