Roarke le da la bienvenida a la presentadora de un programa matutino local, Christine Collins, quien tiene una simple fantasía: quiere comer. Y come. Y come. Pero cuando Christine llegue a Fantasy Island, se dará cuenta de que tiene hambre de mucho más que comida. Los otros invitados de Roarke incluyen a Ruby Akuda, que padece una enfermedad terminal y recibe una nueva oportunidad de vida.

Dos aventureros, cuyo matrimonio se ha estancado, quieren vivir la aventura definitiva juntos. Mientras tanto, después de dormir durante 35 años, el viudo Brent, debe decidir si está listo para enfrentar su dolor despierto.

La excéntrica y extravagante Eileen quiere pasar tiempo con su hija separada y su familia, pero se niegan a verla. El desilusionado profesor de física Charles quiere saber si hay algo más por ahí.

Nisha wants the island to help her decide between marrying her parent's proposed match, Savin, or her longtime boyfriend, Josh.

When old friends Nettie, Camille and Margot come to the island to celebrate their 50th birthdays, their fantasies expose fault lines in their friendship.

A bookworm who wants to say yes to life goes back in time to meet her favorite author, and a competitive survivalist learns that the ultimate challenge is something he hasn’t trained for.

A young artist Ramon wants to see his mentor, Jasper, again and Jasper realizes he may not have been the best influence on Ramon.

A businesswoman's fantasy of a perfect Christmas and to meet "Mr. Right" tests Roarke in unexpected ways. Meanwhile, Mr. Jones faces his past, while a new Secret Santa tradition has Ruby and Javier looking to the future.

A businesswoman's fantasy of a perfect Christmas and to meet "Mr. Right" tests Roarke in unexpected ways. Meanwhile, Mr. Jones faces his past, while a new Secret Santa tradition has Ruby and Javier looking to the future.