As the debate team acclimates to the slightly unconventional methods of their new teacher, Alicia, friendships are tested when invites to the house party of the year finds only some of them making the exclusive list.

As the debate team dodges unwanted attention, Luke tries to correct the situation, Alicia goes to great lengths to convince Robyn to lead the group, and Terrell attempts to recruit Sarah in hopes of spending more time with her.

As the school play approaches, Alicia helps Miles step out of his comfort zone to audition. After Sarah finally agrees to hang, Terrell’s friends make him question whether it’s really a date.

After accidentally ruining Elliot’s date, Alicia becomes his profile guru. Meanwhile, Makayla’s girls’ night leads to unintended fallout with Luke, and Miles becomes Principal Maris’ apprentice – but for the most unexpected reason.

While Luke and Terrell seize a lucrative sneaker opportunity, the girls learn how to control their own narrative, and Alicia confronts her greatest challenge yet: PTA moms.

Realizing that she’s overhyped – but underprepared – her team, Alicia aims to course correct ahead of their first debate. Luke learns that landing a popular kid’s endorsement is harder than running for class treasurer.

When Elliot’s public reading of Sarah’s poem tanks, Alicia rethinks her tendency to meddle in the affairs of others. Miles, Robyn, and Luke attempt to go phoneless.

After qualifying for the World Debate League Invitational, the team scrambles to secure funding for the tournament.

The group offers Miles advice on asking Griffin to the Winter Formal, while Alicia considers her future at the school after an unscheduled meeting with the superintendent.