Ice cream store manager and church league basketball coach Robbie goes after his dream job and gets some shocking news from his ex-girlfriend.

When Robbie seeks to baptize Caleb so he can play on the church basketball team, Ava demands that Robbie first step up as a dad financially.

Robbie tries turning the public against the new high school basketball coach so he can claim the job for himself, and Robbie Sr. embraces retirement.

Robbie attempts to befriend the team's parents at Ava's suggestion, but his immature behavior and hostile attitude get in the way.

The arrival of a new boutique ice cream chain pits Robbie against his dad and gives Ava a chance to meet her hero.

Robbie tries to get uniforms for his team, but raising the funds requires him to pack the crowd for the next game, and Ava tours a prospective private school for Caleb.

At Caleb's birthday party, Ava gets frustrated at her bossy older sister and Robbie finds out that Ava lied about how their relationship ended.