I agree to Sport. I miss this genre here, a keyword for this isn't enough imo. the others no.. having 100 genres would generate chaos. I would also welcome 'short' even though I can live quite well with it being a keyword.
I can certainly see adding film noir; but sport is problematic, because it is really more of a vague content area, and as such, it intersects/overlaps with so many existing genres: drama, comedy, documentary, etc.
to sort short films they solved it by declaring anything under 41 mins as short film.. They really should work on that custom genres based on keywords thing Marr mentioned, sounds like a brilliant idea.
to sort short films they solved it by declaring anything under 41 mins as short film.. They really should work on that custom genres based on keywords thing Marr mentioned, sounds like a brilliant idea.
I don't know if you can see the page if you don't have an account, but for movies they created genres like "Anime"; "Holiday"; "Musical" (alongside Music, they're two separate genres to filter on!); "Sporting Event" and "Superhero" among others I think.
They also created custom genres for TV. Like Home and Garden, Soap etc.
So whats the diference between History or Music and Sports? Why are the first two included but not the third?
As you seem interested in the topic, it might be worth reading this thread.
There are several theses defenses of what should and shouldn't be on the Movie Genre list.
Genres - Movies
There is a topic especially for Movie Genres. https://www.themoviedb.org/talk/51b5fe1a760ee359996a0e62
This implementation work has been stalled for some time.
But I believe that when work is resumed, this will be the basic topic for implementation.
So I suggest you post your request there.
Bananaからの返信
投稿:2020年10月18日 6:22 PM
Many of these are keywords eg. sports or superhero
warnerchildからの返信
投稿:2020年10月21日 10:32 AM
Yeah I said Genre
not keyword.....
warnerchildからの返信
投稿:2020年10月24日 4:05 AM
Is there a list of all the keywords?
Bananaからの返信
投稿:2020年10月24日 5:52 AM
It's part of the daily exports: https://developers.themoviedb.org/3/getting-started/daily-file-exports
warnerchildからの返信
投稿:2020年10月25日 10:25 AM
Thank you
Davidからの返信
投稿:2021年03月21日 6:23 PM
I agree to Sport. I miss this genre here, a keyword for this isn't enough imo. the others no.. having 100 genres would generate chaos. I would also welcome 'short' even though I can live quite well with it being a keyword.
Bananaからの返信
投稿:2021年03月21日 6:32 PM
The sport genre was removed before my time. I can't say I've ever had the need for it though.
warnerchildからの返信
投稿:2021年04月06日 2:23 AM
It's a big issue on letterboxd - which is why I was told to come here and ask about it here as this is where they get their stuff
Bananaからの返信
投稿:2021年04月06日 4:51 AM
Is it?
PT 100からの返信
投稿:2021年04月07日 3:46 AM
I can certainly see adding film noir; but sport is problematic, because it is really more of a vague content area, and as such, it intersects/overlaps with so many existing genres: drama, comedy, documentary, etc.
Marr 🇳🇱からの返信
投稿:2021年04月09日 2:52 PM
They could also do it like Trakt and create custom genres based on keywords or other stuff
Just because they don't use all options/get creative, doesn't mean TMDb should overhaul the database.... or add "genres" that aren't genres
Davidからの返信
投稿:2021年04月09日 3:05 PM
to sort short films they solved it by declaring anything under 41 mins as short film.. They really should work on that custom genres based on keywords thing Marr mentioned, sounds like a brilliant idea.
Marr 🇳🇱からの返信
投稿:2021年04月09日 3:09 PM
I don't know if you can see the page if you don't have an account, but for movies they created genres like "Anime"; "Holiday"; "Musical" (alongside Music, they're two separate genres to filter on!); "Sporting Event" and "Superhero" among others I think.
They also created custom genres for TV. Like Home and Garden, Soap etc.
wallygからの返信
投稿:2021年09月19日 4:12 PM
So whats the diference between History or Music and Sports? Why are the first two included but not the third?
ticao2 🇧🇷 pt-BRからの返信
投稿:2021年09月20日 9:26 AM
As you seem interested in the topic, it might be worth reading this thread.
There are several theses defenses of what should and shouldn't be on the Movie Genre list.
Genres - Movies
There is a topic especially for Movie Genres.
https://www.themoviedb.org/talk/51b5fe1a760ee359996a0e62
This implementation work has been stalled for some time.
But I believe that when work is resumed, this will be the basic topic for implementation.
So I suggest you post your request there.