This is (also) something that has been bugging me for a while. There is a prominent focus on a show's creator in the TV database but you will not find any clear definition of that role (aka wiki). What for me is even worse however is that it's not something that every show has or cares about.
Just going by Wikipedia you will already get multiple possible "creator" roles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_program_creators... In the DB I saw all kinds of usage of the field; be it the showrunner (which can change), the author of the first/couple episodes, the author of the source material or even the production company. What is it now and should the field really be this "exclusive" for TV?
Un film, une émission télévisée ou un artiste est introuvable ? Connectez-vous afin de créer une nouvelle fiche.
Vous souhaitez évaluer ou ajouter cet élément à une liste ?
Pas encore membre ?
Réponse de Marr 🇳🇱
le 28 janvier 2017 à 08h45
I think the creator is just the person who is specifically credited that way -- "Created by XXX" or "Developed by XXX", or list that on the official website. It's true that not all shows have that, and in that case I leave it empty. Showrunners don't count as creators, as they change indeed. They are just the main producer/writer, if I understand correctly.
I think I also saw the "created by" in one of two movies, but I think that isn't really a thing for movies.
Réponse de sp1ti
le 28 janvier 2017 à 09h10
But if it has to be an explicit credit then the potential "targets" for this will be even fewer. I don't have a problem with the credit existing but more of how prominent it is in the DB... just leads to more "wrong" uses (by whatever definition).
Réponse de Travis Bell
le 28 janvier 2017 à 10h46
@alltimemarr is right, it's just about who created it. If a show doesn't have a creator that it cares about, it's ok to leave it empty. It's true that perhaps only recently (as in the last decade) do TV shows make a bigger deal of its creator but I know personally, as a fan of some specific creators I think of them more like a big Hollywood director. People care about about the new David Fincher film because it's David Fincher. Same goes for a TV show's creator. Knowing that Bryan Fuller was behind Hannibal was all I needed to add it to my watchlist. I've loved everything he's done going all the way back to Dead Like Me.
Réponse de Marr 🇳🇱
le 28 janvier 2017 à 10h48
Yeah that is true, I've seen with some anime that the creator of the original work (light novel, manga w/e) was added there too :-P
I don't know why it is really such a prominent place.
Maybe it could be on the crew page. I think there is (or used to be) a "Creator" crewjob too! And then just show that on the page if desidered. Much like the writer/directors are shown for episodes and movies.
Réponse de sp1ti
le 28 janvier 2017 à 11h33
I know what you mean Travis but it's those older titles and the content that doesn't care about it that makes it a questionable field to be promoted this exclusively. It's ok to show up at the front but the credit should go to the crew and other roles be shown if it's not filled out imho.
Réponse de sp1ti
le 23 août 2017 à 06h35
Just checking again: I can delete anyone from the staff, studios themselves and the creators of the original work from the field right? Because at this point I see them added to every anime under the moon... By definition this TV "core field will rarely be used for anime The "bible" is still MIA?
Réponse de Banana
le 23 août 2017 à 07h00
Pretty much. I think you can safely remove anyone who didn't write the first episode... and anyone who isn't clearly the creator. I usually make exceptions for series written by a single person or a writing duo. We understand they are the creator(s) even if they are not recognized as such in the credits.
Réponse de sp1ti
le 23 août 2017 à 10h28
This reply doesn't make it more clear to me given the "first episode" note... @alltimemarr & @travisbell suggested that it should be an explicit credit which would be easy to make out... Going by "involvement" is a lot more difficult. In case of anime for example (with not as much "original" programming) most would attribute it to the main director of a show but he usually isn't alone in this as there is also someone doing series composition (which usually gets attributed to the creator role in addition to just writing) as well as individual episode directors, storyboarders and script writers as in other media. In addition to that there is a lot of reliance on visuals which is often also driven by the studio entities and makes them recognizable or the talent they have working. Something like for example "Gurren Lagann would not exist or play out like it does if it was made by a different Studio than Gainax.
Réponse de sp1ti
le 23 décembre 2017 à 07h46
So can we get this adjusted someday? I'm constantly deleting original creators off adaptions because people are not filling in the proper credits and the sole reason for that is that it's badly explained and you're forcing the field into people's faces... just link to the regular credits and have it show up there if set OR let us pick what the creator is. Be it production company, director or what else...
Réponse de Travis Bell
le 26 décembre 2017 à 12h02
Yup, definitely on my list.
Réponse de sp1ti
le 13 avril 2018 à 11h24
I'm deleting creators of the source material on anime in multitudes from new shows btw. and found even locked ones https://www.themoviedb.org/talk/5ac5489c0e0a260c4a05e9fa. Hopefully this gets addressed sooner than later. Imho a (?) hint would already help a bit or just change it up like it's on movies (force the credit selection and allow authors to be included)...
Réponse de Travis Bell
le 13 avril 2018 à 11h34
Yup, that can be done.
I already removed the placeholder "We don't have any crew added to this TV Show..." 2 (or 3?) weeks ago, which should also be helping.
Réponse de sp1ti
le 13 avril 2018 à 11h53
Thanks but just the mere fact that it's one of few fields on the "primary facts" still leads to it being filled out ;)...
Réponse de sp1ti
le 4 janvier 2019 à 10h23
I have been filling in main director and series composition credits in the "created by" field on anime shows for a while now - as I said I would do in another thread - without anyone removing them, but now noticed that Marr deleted a few of them. So that is now no longer OK ;)? So "Created by" TMDB area is solely for the US (WGA) TV definition of the term - amen (as in the bible)?
(I just noticed that the "Featured crew" area isn't actually showing up anymore if empty so that lowers the issue at last ;))
Réponse de Marr 🇳🇱
le 4 janvier 2019 à 11h14
I probably didn't notice that thread. And it's true, I deleted them! (maybe I should have messaged you, I'm not yet really in the habit of doing that, only with real spam. Sorry D:)
It's still in my mind that only credited creators are added that's why indeed. Probably only recent anime exception being Aggretsuko
That's indeed huge improvement