讨论 Les Sentiers de la Gloire
讨论 → 电影 → Les Sentiers de la Gloire → 一般问题
This movie broke me
VingoSTAFFMOD 发布于 2018 年 01 月 30 日 6:48下午
I watched this movie for the first time last night and besides being a visual masterpiece, the ending left me broken and traumatised. I just sat there silently after the film ended even though it was well into the night and I had to get up early for work. I don't think I've ever felt this upset with a film's ending since I watched Nanjing! Nanjing! (or City of Life and Death) a few years back.
tmdb53400018 的回复
于 2018 年 04 月 07 日 6:42下午
SPOILERS BELOW.
The soldiers' pretty much inconsolable fear at knowing they'd be executed for their "cowardice" is very hard to watch. Not at all "macho" behavior, and therefore, they didn't die "macho" deaths. So I feel you on your post. Man, Kubrick is a once-every-hundred-years director if ever there was one.
Nexus71 的回复
于 2019 年 04 月 27 日 6:03下午
Playing tonight on BBC 2 The ending is really a tearjerker if anybody claims that Kubrick is a cold, detached emotionless director you should let them watch this movie and even though the ending is bleak the scene with Christiane is not only highly emotional but also raises a glimmer of hope.
genplant29 的回复
于 2020 年 02 月 06 日 1:09上午
RIP Kirk Douglas (1916-2020), age 103.
rooprect 的回复
于 2023 年 02 月 26 日 7:25上午
Just watched this last night, like you, sat there in silence after the credits went dark. Then watched all the bonus interviews and watched the movie again with the commentary track.
A true masterpiece and definitely the hardest gut punch I’ve ever gotten from a war movie (a genre based on gut punches). I knew Kubrick’s films have a cynical slant but wow, this one out-cynics even Clockwork Orange. I think it’s because Clockwork—and a lot of bitter pill films of the cold war 60s-70s-80s—had a certain satirical sneer, a dark comedy twist that gives the audience an odd sense of comfort in absurdity; whereas Paths has no such cheekiness. The darkness is pure dark.
Wait, correction. It’s not pure dark. Even worse, there’s a pale, malformed glow of hope that proves to be utterly powerless against the machine of war & folly of man. In this case it’s the impotent old priest in the last act promising empty “thoughts and prayers” even as he literally leads them straight to the shooting post. And in one of the greatest shows of cinematic irony it’s the young German girl’s singing which brings the soldiers to tears in one last display of humanity before the film’s punchline: “Give the men a few minutes” (before sending them to their deaths).
One thing I was surprised to learn from the commentary was that Kubrick originally wanted to give the film a happy ending where the men are saved. Surely that’s what we were all hoping for (and I genuinely expected it), but he was talked out of it… possibly by Kirk Douglas himself. The result is bleak as hell but certainly fitting. No war movie can end happy.