Cast 31

1. 

   Lauren Holly

   Audrey Valentine

2. 

   Brian Krause

   Daniel Valentine

3. 

   Jeremy Sumpter

   Connor

4. 

   Caitlin E.J. Meyer

   Lily Valentine

5. 

   Danielle C. Ryan

   Emma Valentine

6. Amanda Gallo

   Ashley

7. 

   Melise

   Megan

8. Chad Hively

   Elliot

9. Jessica Jackson

   Piper

10. Susan Phelan

    Mrs. Porter

11. 

    Zack Phifer

    Principal Barlow

12. 

    Logan Rogan

    Marvin

13. 

    Nikola Clark

    Rita

14. Dayne Rockwood

    Tyler

15. Michael James Brown

    Pizza Delivery Guy

16. Juliette Lyde

    Young Emma Valentine

17. Grace Hallows

    Young Lily Valentine

18. 

    Lindsay Bird

    Young Audrey

19. Aaliyah Lightfoot

    Cute Girl

20. Luke Porter

    Wentworth

21. Ethan Lyde

    Kissing Boy

22. Monique Baird

    Kissing Girl

23. Adam Baird

    Pretentious Thug

24. Zack Bullock

    Handsome Thug

25. Adam Kaiser

    Really Cute Boy

26. 

    Shalaina Castle

    Candice

27. Bryton Catlett

    Student (uncredited)

28. Christopher K. Hagadone

    Kickball Player (uncredited)

29. Crystal Sargent

    Student (uncredited)

30. 

    Stacey Ann Turner

    Student (uncredited)

31. Lauren Wright

    Student (uncredited)

Troupe 10