Discussão 亂世佳人

How can anyone sympathise with Scarlett and Gerald in that scene when they treat the Slatteries horribly? And for classist reasons too!

6 respostas (na página 1 de 1)

Jump to last post

Very true. Of course how we view the Slatterys through present-day eyes vs. how they would have been perceived either back during the 1800s or in the 1930s are two very different things. Now we, in large part, view Scarlett and her father as being total jerks towards the Slatterys, whereas people in past generations would have seen the Slatterys as unacceptable social pariahs of trashy character and low morals, outcasts of their own making, who "good folk" should have absolutely nothing to do with.

Yeah, tis true! However, it does make it extremely hard to sympathise with Gerald's death

If I recall accurately (and may definitely be mistaken), it was from going to help tend the Slatterys' new (I think out of wedlock?) baby that Mrs. O'Hara's death was brought on (via exposure to contagion or whatever). Therefore the O'Haras already utterly despise the Slatterys due to that, as they feel like the Slatterys literally killed their matriarch.

I bought the GwtW DVD a month or so ago, and so far have watched it only once (and hadn't seen the movie otherwise in probably 5+ years, though numerous times way back in the '70s and '80s), so remain a bit rusty on certain details specifics, and intend to watch it again probably sometime during the next few months.

I think you are right

The Slattery family was not looked upon with favor not only because they were poor, but because they were freeloaders. The father's talents were drinking moonshine and repeatedly getting his wife pregnant with one baby after another that they didn't want to work to take care of. Then he would go and beg from the neighbors. Supposedly, some of the landowners had offered to buy his land for far more than it was worth to be rid of them, but were turned down because they would rather hang around and mooch.

Thanks for the great info, Asharah.

I really need to reread the novel (which I have a hardcover copy of on my bookshelf) one of these days. I read it a couple times decades back, but no longer am able to recall much beyond what's in the movie version.

Não consegue encontrar um certo Filme ou Série? Inicie Sessão e adicione-o.

Geral

s focus the search bar
p abrir menu do perfil
esc close an open window
? open keyboard shortcut window

Em páginas de Média

b go back (or to parent when applicable)
e ir para a página de edição

Em Páginas de Temporadas de Séries

(seta para a direita) ir para a próxima temporada
(seta para a esquerda) ir para a temporada anterior

Em Páginas de Episódios de Séries

(seta para a direita) ir para o próximo episódio
(seta para a esquerda) ir para o episódio anterior

Em Todas as Páginas de Imagens

a abrir janela para adicionar imagem

Em Todas as Páginas de Edição

t open translation selector
ctrl+ s submit form

Em Páginas de Discussão

n criar uma nova discussão
w toggle watching status
p toggle public/private
c toggle close/open
a abrir actividade
r reply to discussion
l ir para a última resposta
ctrl+ enter submit your message
(seta para a direita) página seguinte
(seta para a esquerda) página anterior

Definições

Deseja classificar ou adicionar este item a uma lista?

Iniciar Sessão

Ainda não é um membro?

Crie uma Conta e Adere a Comunidade