讨论 007：金枪人
讨论 → 电影 → 007：金枪人 → 一般问题
Rating Sir Roger's Bond Films
Midi-chlorian_CountSTAFFMOD 发布于 2017 年 04 月 03 日 7:41下午
I recently rewatched all of Sir Roger's efforts and had in mind The Spy Who Loved Me, Moonraker and Octopussy as his crowning glories. However, I think I was perhaps unfairly elevating Octopussy just above this as I was so pleased to see it match the tone of those other two following For Your Eyes Only.
In truth though I think this is a slightly better film overall, even with the slightly inferior tone of his first couple of outings. Therefore I'd go:-
- Moonraker
- The Spy Who Loved Me
- The Man With The Golden Gun
- Octopussy
- Live and Let Die
- A View To A Kill
- For Your Eyes Only
How do other Sir Roger fans rate his entries?
Drooch 的回复
于 2017 年 04 月 03 日 8:15下午
It's a fantastic era actually. Such entertaining films - funny, fantastical, but still elegant, and often surreal. In order of how much I like them (not necessarily how good they are as films)...
Moonraker
A View To A Kill (best Bond villain)
For Your Eyes Only
Live and Let Die
The Man With The Golden Gun
Octopussy
The Spy Who Loved Me
Dawn Of The Ed 的回复
于 2017 年 04 月 03 日 8:57下午
The Spy Who Loved Me
For Your Eyes Only
Live And Let Die
The Man With The Golden Gun
A View To A Kill
Moonraker
Octopussy (The only Bond film I truly dislike)
Midi-chlorian_Count 的回复
于 2017 年 04 月 04 日 6:00下午
Just wondering if there was any particular reasoning behind this?
Although I wouldn't have gone as far as to say I disliked it, prior to my recent rewatching I'd probably have placed it near the bottom too just going off my memory.
Was never a huge fan of the clown circus tent ending...
Dawn Of The Ed 的回复
于 2017 年 04 月 04 日 7:09下午
I felt that Roger Moore was starting to feel like a Bond parody at this point. I generally love the Moore era Bond flicks but Octopussy never worked for me because of that. I also didn't like Louis Jourdan as Kamal. He was a boring villian.
I'll try to give it another watch. It's been a good five years since I've seen it. Maybe like you I'll end up appreciating it a bit more.
elliotthomas97 的回复
于 2017 年 04 月 04 日 7:50下午
I think THE SPY WHO LOVED ME is, by far, Roger's best Bond pic.
rudely_murray 的回复
于 2017 年 04 月 04 日 8:23下午
7
6
5
4
3
elliotthomas97 的回复
于 2017 年 04 月 04 日 8:29下午
That's a pretty spot-on assessment. I dunno what to make of the Timothy Dalton ones. Living Daylights was traditional enough, then Licence to Kill was R-rated and violent (by Bond standards). Dalton and Moore are so hard to compare
Maria Kelly 的回复
于 2018 年 06 月 24 日 3:39下午
I've never been a big Roger Moore fan, but some of his Bond movies were quite entertaining. My rankings:
1)The Spy Who Loved Me
2)For Your Eyes Only
3)Octopussy
4)Moonraker
5)A View To A Kill
6)Live And Let Die
7) The Man With The Golden Gun