Cast 65

1. 

   Billy Eichner

   Bobby

2. 

   Luke Macfarlane

   Aaron

3. 

   Guy Branum

   Henry

4. 

   Miss Lawrence

   Wanda

5. 

   Ts Madison

   Angela

6. 

   Dot-Marie Jones

   Cherry

7. 

   Jim Rash

   Robert

8. 

   Eve Lindley

   Tamara

9. 

   Monica Raymund

   Tina

10. 

    Guillermo Díaz

    Edgar

11. 

    Jai Rodriguez

    Jason

12. 

    Amanda Bearse

    Anne

13. 

    Debra Messing

    Debra Messing

14. 

    Peter Y. Kim

    Peter

15. 

    Justin Covington

    Paul

16. 

    Symone

    Marty

17. 

    Ryan Faucett

    Josh

18. 

    Becca Blackwell

    Lucas

19. D'Lo

    Tom

20. 

    Harvey Fierstein

    Louis

21. 

    Bowen Yang

    Lawrence Grape

22. Dahlia Rodriguez

    Hannah

23. 

    Derrick Delgado

    Brian

24. 

    George Dvorsky

    Bruce

25. 

    Jamyl Dobson

    Joel

26. 

    Brock Ciarlelli

    Steve

27. 

    Kenan Thompson

    James Baldwin

28. 

    Amy Schumer

    Eleanor Roosevelt

29. 

    Jillian Gottlieb

    Samantha

30. 

    Rick Crom

    Grape's Neighbor

31. 

    Everett Quinton

    Melvin Funk

32. Thomas Vorsteg

    Polyamorous Man

33. Julia Scotti

    Straight Older Woman

34. Feliziano Flores

    Rowdy Bear

35. Allison Reese

    Aaron's Assistant

36. Gara Lonning

    Receptionist

37. 

    Nanie Méndez

    Party Guest

38. Eileen Noonan

    Party Guest

39. Courtney Chu

    Teenage Girl

40. Ryan Daly

    Grindr Guy

41. Brayden Morgan

    Judgey Boy

42. 

    William Popp

    Pride Awards Football Player

43. 

    Aidan Wharton

    Football Player

44. Jovan E'Sean

    Football Player

45. Joey Taranto

    Singing Waiter

46. Courtney Bassett

    Singing Waiter

47. Joshua L.K. Patterson

    Singing Waiter

48. 

    Kristin Chenoweth

    Kristin Chenoweth

49. Edythe Jason

    Paul's Grandma

50. Lorenzo Scott

    Paul's Grandpa

51. Keith Milkie

    Baseball Player

52. Alex Ringler

    Baseball Player's Man

53. Cedric Leiba, Jr.

    Harness Guy

54. Clayton Paterson

    Hot Santa

55. Legendary Monster Babylon

    Vogueing Man

56. Doug Trapp

    Movie Exec

57. Jesús Martínez Jr.

    Drag Queen

58. Daren J. Fleming

    Drag Queen

59. 

    Shannon O'Neill

    Paula

60. 

    Matthew Wilkas

    Handsome Grindr Guy

61. Charles J. Roby

    Wealthy Benefactor

62. 

    Ben Stiller

    Ben Stiller (uncredited)

63. 

    Seth Meyers

    Harvey Milk (uncredited)

64. 

    Anthony DeVito

    Straight Liberal Dad (uncredited)

65. 

    Joanne Lamstein

    Straight Liberal Mom (uncredited)

Crew 50