The Band's Visit 토론

...and brilliantly done. This movie is all about the disconnection between people, drawing humor out of the awkwardness. What's interesting is how the camera sets up the comedy without any dialogue or sometimes without any movement at all.

The opening scene is a great example of the sort of camera humor I'm talking about. It's a very stationary, very symmetrical shot of a long white van parked neatly between 2 grey columns. Beyond this white van is an equally colorless landscape. For a few seconds there's literally nothing to look at. Then the driver door opens, a man gets out & slowly walks to the back of the van and opens it. He pulls out a huge yellow ball, holding it the way you might hold a giant wedding cake, walking stiffly back to the driver door, tossing it in, then getting in and driving off.

We never get an explanation for that bizarre sight, nor do we care, because suddenly we're confronted with the real gag. As the white van drives off like a curtain being pulled back, it reveals behind it a bunch of policemen dressed in bright baby blue suits. Without a word spoken, we know what this movie as about: these guys stand out like a bunch of sore thumbs.

The policemen are the protagonists in our film: an Egyptian police band dropped in the middle of Israel. In case you missed it, Egyptian-Israeli relations were rather frosty in the 80s-90s. But aside from that premise the film doesn't dwell on political or cultural divisions. The premise is just the perfect metaphor for the personal disconnection & frostiness between humans. Everyone seems to have a wall between them, blocking the real view just like that white van in the beginning.

Despite the comical presentation, the film has plenty of serious stuff to say if you read between the lines. To me the dramatic highlight--and the meaning of the movie--is the scene with the clarinet player who can't come up with an ending for his concerto. The scene is late at night between him an his reluctant Israeli host, both sitting quietly in a baby's room. The host fumbles for words, then says, "Maybe your concerto should end like this, no loud trumpets or violins but just this, a small room... a lamp, a bed... child sleeping.... and tons of loneliness."

2 댓글 (1 / 1)

Jump to last post

It's been a while since I saw this film but I remember loving it. I gave it an 8/10. I should give it another watch.

@bratface said:

It's been a while since I saw this film but I remember loving it. I gave it an 8/10. I should give it another watch.

I think it's a great time to see it again, especially in light of recent events... I just watched the Behind the Scenes mini doc and they mentioned how it was a great collaboration between Israelis and Palestinians, Jews & Arabs. Everyone worked together, had a great time and made a fun film with a lot of heart!

찾으시는 영화나 TV 프로그램이 없나요? 로그인 하셔서 직접 만들어주세요.

전체

s 검색 바 띄우기
p 프로필 메뉴 열기
esc 열린 창 닫기
? 키보드 단축키 창 열기

미디어 페이지

b 돌아가기
e 편집 페이지로 이동

TV 시즌 페이지

(우 화살표) 다음 시즌으로 가기
(좌 화살표) 이전 시즌으로 가기

TV 에피소드 페이지

(우 화살표) 다음 에피소드로 가기
(좌 화살표) 이전 에피소드로 가기

모든 이미지 페이지

a 이미지 추가 창 열기

모든 편집 페이지

t 번역 선택 열기
ctrl+ s 항목 저장

토론 페이지

n 새 토론 만들기
w 보기 상태
p 공개/비공개 전환
c 열기/닫기 전환
a 활동 열기
r 댓글에 글쓰기
l 마지막 댓글로 가기
ctrl+ enter 회원님의 메세지 제출
(우 화살표) 다음 페이지
(좌 화살표) 이전 페이지

설정

Want to rate or add this item to a list?

로그인