Based on our rules, a stand up comedy show directly released physically (VHS or DVD) should have the video attribute set.

it's not only physical it's also not Netflix and other streaming sites would that still fall under video?

I don't see it on Netflix. Do you have a proof that it was available on an official streaming site before the DVD (with the release date) ?

Based on Wikipedia, it was only TV broadcasted after the DVD release. So, the video attribute should be set.

https://www.reddit.com/r/netflix/comments/adrd4z/tim_minchin_so_fking_rock_now_streaming/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share The post is dated January 8th, 2019 so i believe that's the date.

THE NETFLIX LISTING: https://www.reddit.com/r/netflix/comments/adrd4z/tim_minchin_so_fking_rock_now_streaming/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

it seems to have been released on streaming after the DVD release. Would that still qualify it?

As the first release was on DVD, the video attribute should be set.

But if it's available on streaming later shouldn't that attribute be removed because plenty of comedy specials don't have that attribute and are on letterboxd. why leave this one out? it deserves to be there.

@mathjews said:

But if it's available on streaming later shouldn't that attribute be removed

No.

Pretty please?

I found proof on Tim Minchin's blog, he made a post stating that this special would be played again on the TV channel E4 (Channel 4). So I still believe the attribute should be swtiched to no for video because I have proof that this special did play on TV more than once when it was released. https://www.timminchin.com/2009/10/29/%e2%80%98so-fking-rock%e2%80%99-on-tv-again/

@mathjews said:

I found proof on Tim Minchin's blog, he made a post stating that this special would be played again on the TV channel E4 (Channel 4). So I still believe the attribute should be swtiched to no for video because I have proof that this special did play on TV more than once when it was released. https://www.timminchin.com/2009/10/29/%e2%80%98so-fking-rock%e2%80%99-on-tv-again/

That does not negate the fact that this was originally released on DVD.