Cast 16

1. 

   Audra McDonald

   Caroler

2. 

   Zosia Mamet

   Bella

3. 

   Jim Gaffigan

   Santa Claus

4. 

   Eric Jacobson

   Bert / Grover (voice)

5. 

   Matt Vogel

   Count von Count / Constable / Two-Headed Monster (voice)

6. 

   Alan Muraoka

   Alan

7. 

   Suki Lopez

   Nina

8. 

   Caroll Spinney

   Big Bird / Oscar the Grouch (voice)

9. 

   Billy Barkhurst

   Ernie (voice)

10. 

    Jennifer Barnhart

    Holly (voice)

11. 

    Tyler Bunch

    Louie (voice)

12. 

    Leslie Carrara-Rudolph

    Abby Cadabby / Becky (voice) (as Leslie Carrara)

13. 

    Ryan Dillon

    Elmo (voice)

14. 

    Haley Jenkins

    Lavendar Anything Muppet Woman (voice)

15. 

    Carmen Osbahr

    Rosita (voice)

16. 

    David Rudman

    Cookie Monster / Two-Headed Monster (voice)

Crew 9