Cast 46

1. 

   Paul Rudd

   Paul

2. 

   Steve Coogan

   Erasmus

3. 

   Jack Gore

   Bill

4. 

   Alison Pill

   Melissa

5. 

   Jake McDorman

   Beau

6. 

   Jesse Luken

   Director

7. 

   Lora Martinez-Cunningham

   Ms. Garcia

8. 

   Sarah Minnich

   Crack Head Lady

9. 

   Stafford Douglas

   Caterer

10. 

    Jacob Browne

    Judge Pierce

11. 

    Frances Lee McCain

    Doris

12. Josey Smith

    Whitney

13. 

    Kate Walsh

    Kate

14. 

    Jenny Gabrielle

    Betty

15. 

    Monique Candelaria

    Officer Guttierez

16. Alexandra Guarnaschelli

    Alex Guarnaschelli

17. 

    Courtney Cunningham

    Paramedic

18. 

    Drew Droege

    Drew

19. 

    Marie Wagenman

    Little Girl

20. 

    Cassandra Rochelle Fetters

    Party Goer

21. 

    Evan Bittencourt

    Tino

22. Rodrigo Tactaquin

    Biker

23. 

    Mark Rowe

    Suburban Dad

24. Eric Womack

    Officer Forrest

25. 

    Richard Beal

    Church Member

26. 

    Jordyn Aurora Aquino

    Leticia

27. 

    Clint Obenchain

    Waiter

28. 

    J. Nathan Simmons

    Wise Man #1

29. Alexander Daniel Pimentel

    Suburban Dad's Friend

30. Kristin Berg

    Taco Bell Manager

31. Emma Armstrong

    Checkout Girl

32. Stephen Conn

    Christmas Reveler / Church decorator / Lighting tech

33. Michael E. Stogner

    Drunk Santa (uncredited)

34. Amanda Quintana-Bowles

    Christmas Reveler

35. Alison Grainger

    Taco Bell Patron

36. Rick Tadra

    Maddy

37. Patrick V. Murphy

    Party goer

38. Ian Morris

    Bill's Friend

39. Ronnie Gomez

    Wise Man #3

40. Jeremiah Fresquez

    Student #1

41. Viola Valdez

    Parishioner

42. Justin Lotz

    Wise Man #2

43. Mason Howell

    Bills Friend

44. 

    Sheila Eden

    Tango Wife (uncredited)

45. 

    Sylvie Grontis Hagan

    Teacher (uncredited)

46. Amy Emily Stack

    Inmate Visitor (uncredited)

Troupe 14