Cast 41

1. 

   Liam James

   Solomon

2. 

   Sarah Steele

   Diwata

3. 

   Austin P. McKenzie

   Howie

4. 

   Janeane Garofalo

   Marie

5. 

   Kal Penn

   James

6. 

   Roger Bart

   Principal Bellingham

7. 

   Wendi McLendon-Covey

   Joan

8. 

   Kimberly Williams-Paisley

   Susan

9. 

   Skylar Astin

   Walter Healy

10. 

    Sarah Baker

    Miss Riggi

11. 

    Darren Criss

    Himself

12. 

    Kristin Chenoweth

    Herself

13. Cristina Franco

    Oksana

14. 

    Ryan Lee

    Mark

15. 

    Edgar Arreola

    Arnett

16. 

    Karen Beyer

    Persuasive Speaking Judge

17. 

    Orlette Cutrer

    Teacher

18. 

    Lucy DeVito

    Lucy

19. 

    Sara Thomas Easley

    Nervous Freshman Girl

20. 

    Sam Furman

    Student

21. 

    Angel Giuffria

    Girl in Motorized Wheelchair

22. 

    Gideon Glick

    Gideon

23. 

    Jessy Hughes

    Goth Girl

24. 

    Bradley K. Jones

    Student

25. Jerry Leggio

    Ted

26. 

    Karen Kaia Livers

    Nurse

27. 

    Anna Margaret

    Casey

28. 

    David Militello

    Plump Boy

29. 

    Lin-Manuel Miranda

    The Genie

30. 

    Tara Shay Montgomery

    Young Drag Queen

31. 

    Robert Peters

    Coach Pemberton

32. 

    Nicholas James Reilly

    Holy Ghost Junior

33. 

    Bryce Romero

    Short Kid

34. 

    Jeremy Rowley

    Gary Crenshaw

35. 

    Ben Sanders

    Student

36. 

    Logan Shroyer

    Hot Debater

37. 

    Amitoz Singh

    DI Boy

38. 

    Lester Speight

    Scary Bouncer

39. 

    George Thagard

    Mayor

40. 

    Sloane Warren

    Fiona Crenshaw

41. 

    Rachel Wulff

    Reporter

Troupe 6