Yes. Technically speaking I haven't seen TLJ, and don't have the inclination too. I also haven't seen Revenge of the Sith. I gave them both two chances.

I dont like the prequels as masterpieces but they are funny as hell with how bad they really are. Let me ask you this Gus what is your opinion on Georges "fixes" in the special editions of the original trilogy?

@Gus Gorman said:

Does such a person exist in Star Wars fandom?

I can't say I'm quite there. There are parts of the prequels I like enough to not totally hate them (Maul, pod race, Geonosis action sequence), and Revenge of the Sith is about 60/40 good. Rogue One is about 50/50 because the first half sucks but the last half is kind of amazing.

TFA I find to be mostly boring. It starts off ok, but after they leave Jakku it goes downhill, and after Kylo takes off it gets even worse. TLJ is a total failure. Even the one really cool moment, the hyperspace ram, loses its cool factor once you realize how badly it breaks the story.

But I will admit, the number of bad SW movies outweighs the number of good ones.

They probobly do exist, but I actually like the prequels, Revenge of the Sith is up there as one of the best Star Wars films in my opinion. I’ve been let down with Disney Star Wars, especially last Jedi.

Didn't like the prequels at first, but once I learned what Lucas was supposed to do with Jar Jar, and after I rewatched it, well, it's not that bad, still weak but has potential, sad story.

And beside Rogue One that was decent, TFA and TLJ are pure crap, didn't see Solo, don't care...

@mcse2000ca said:

I dont like the prequels as masterpieces but they are funny as hell with how bad they really are. Let me ask you this Gus what is your opinion on Georges "fixes" in the special editions of the original trilogy?

Some of the alterations I don't mind; The Death Star explosion, Cloud City now having windows and the removal of matte lines in all 3 movies. Everything else is meh.

Hates, no. Strongly dislikes or is indifferent to? Sure. I thought the two worst were, for different reasons, Attack of the Clones and The Last Jedi. The first because it was a terrible film from beginning to end, and the last because it needlessly undermined the characters from the original trilogy (and ruined Finn from TFA) in an all-out effort to put them to bed so that Disney could promote its new action figures. The rest I've watched once, or at most twice, and I find that they're simply not entertaining enough to watch again.

I suppose you wanted strong emotions, but I can't really muster any. There has been much better Sci-Fi on television for the last few decades than has been in the theaters. Oh, and I have no intention of ever seeing Solo. I've never been interested in seeing other actors' interpretations of roles that living actors originated. I never cared who Solo was before ANH and I still don't.

@Gus Gorman said:

Does such a person exist in Star Wars fandom?

I didn't hate HATE the Prequels before Darth Mickey Sequels but now I consider them Masterpieces and George Lucas a misunderstood genius!!! I hate ST so hard that it fully and utterly redeemed PT for me. Thank Kathleen Kennedy, Jar Jar Abrahams and Rian Johnson for that. Hooray!!!

@Gus Gorman said:

@mcse2000ca said:

I dont like the prequels as masterpieces but they are funny as hell with how bad they really are. Let me ask you this Gus what is your opinion on Georges "fixes" in the special editions of the original trilogy?

Some of the alterations I don't mind; The Death Star explosion, Cloud City now having windows and the removal of matte lines in all 3 movies. Everything else is meh.

ahh but for every favorable fix he did he did 3 of han stepping on Jabbas tail shudder lol

@komrad said:

@Gus Gorman said:

Does such a person exist in Star Wars fandom?

I didn't hate HATE the Prequels before Darth Mickey Sequels but now I consider them Masterpieces and George Lucas a misunderstood genius!!! I hate ST so hard that it fully and utterly redeemed PT for me. Thank Kathleen Kennedy, Jar Jar Abrahams and Rian Johnson for that. Hooray!!!

Yep, this is pretty much where I stand.👍

Hate is such a strong word. Only one I've truly enjoyed was TFA and look forward to JJ Abrams taking back directing reigns for Ep 9 (Love what he did with Star Trek too)

What I DO hate is Disney milking the shizz out of SW at every turn! Its ridiculous! Solo came way too quickly...not to mention TLJ still left a sour taste in many...bad timing!

@komrad said:

@Gus Gorman said:

Does such a person exist in Star Wars fandom?

I didn't hate HATE the Prequels before Darth Mickey Sequels but now I consider them Masterpieces and George Lucas a misunderstood genius!!! I hate ST so hard that it fully and utterly redeemed PT for me. Thank Kathleen Kennedy, Jar Jar Abrahams and Rian Johnson for that. Hooray!!!

These are my thoughts exactly, after Disney star Wars, the prequels magically became good movies to me. They were here all along and I didn’t see it.

I don't hate the prequels. But i don't care for them either. I differently don't think there great movies. They still pretty horriblely written and acted and don't get me started on the hamfisted creepy romance. So far the only thing that Disney did i enjoyed was Forced Awakens. Even with the obvious flaws. Rouge One bored the hell out of me. As far im concerned everything outside the original trilogy is just fan fiction anyways. Even if some that fan fiction is not that bad. Im mainly talking about books, video games and stuff like that. .

I don't know if this counts but I dislike all of Star Wars movies... The old ones I saw as a child (reruns of the OT) and the latter ones that I saw as an adult (rerurns of the prequels and the new Disney ones in cinema)...

But I am non-fan... So probably doesn't count...

@Damienracer said:

@Renovatio said:

I don't know if this counts but I dislike all of Star Wars movies... The old ones I saw as a child (reruns of the OT) and the latter ones that I saw as an adult (rerurns of the prequels and the new Disney ones in cinema)...

But I am non-fan... So probably doesn't count...

You're a non fan, then what's the point of you stinking up this thread with junk mail? Just because you have fingers doesn't mean you have to reply to any and every topic on here. Some topics just don't need your input so in future if you could just pass a thread that would be great.

The irony... 😘