I don't understand why they made it so that Matthew Fox's character died. He was by far the more likeable of the two. And I think it was horrible that Emma's (brother? friend?) accused him of being the reason why Emma died. It was very unfortunate what happened to Emma, but puhlease, he's just as bad, taking his daughter away, and not trying to help him with his grief. Then not using his gun to kill that thing when it was on top of Matthew Fox's character to save his dog. He just was an unlikeable character, and he got to live? Well, I guess that happens much too often in real life, but... I really would have liked to have a glimmer of a happier ending given the state they were all living in...