Discuti I magnifici sette
Discussioni → Film → I magnifici sette → Generale
What did you think of this remake.
pubblicato da AusFemSTAFFMOD il 11 febbraio, 2017 alle 3:25PM
I didn't like it at all. Actually i don't know why it was called a remake. The characters were all different as was most of the story line. And what was with the American Indian. He seemed to appear out of nowhere.
Risposta da Will Barks
il 11 febbraio, 2017 alle 8:25PM
As a standalone film, I found it quite entertaining. But then again I have a faible for Westerns.
Although I have yet to see the earlier the "original". The Seven Samurai, on which the old remake is based on, I know.
The new remake has enough parallels to Kurosawa's masterpiece to be reminded of it but at the same time standing on its own feet.
Risposta da AlexSlayerZ
il 7 marzo, 2017 alle 9:52AM
Considering I didn't even knew this was a remake of some other movie, I quite enjoyed, but I can't compare it to the original. It's not a remarkable movie but for me it satisfied my Westerns movies "craving". I do agree, a little bit more character background would've helped a lot.
Risposta da DanDare
il 3 febbraio, 2019 alle 8:00PM
The original movie was not even original!
Risposta da lassie
il 4 febbraio, 2019 alle 5:55PM
I liked the 2016 version, but the I thought the 1960 version was better. Seven Samurai is another level above, but I know people who did not like it. The cultural differences, the overall raw feel of it, plus the subtitles make Seven Samurai an acquired taste. I gave 2016 a 7, 1960 an 8 and SS a 9 on IMBD. These 3 movies would make one hell of a movie night!
Risposta da Will Barks
il 5 febbraio, 2019 alle 3:26PM
True!
Risposta da VHS-VANDAL
il 7 febbraio, 2019 alle 7:44PM
ITS A BIG FUN ACTION FLICK.GREAT HAMMY PERFORMANCES AND A N ICE TWISTY TAKE ON THE ORIGINALS PLOT AND DEATH ORDER.