"I gave you back the map, Heather! I gave you BACK...the MAP!" - Not sure if it's the best line but the way Josh said it. Really hard to choose from so many good ones.

@howardburns Oh definitely! One of my favorites as well.

And... "Heather you're gonna make me yell at you man...you're gonna make me yell at you."

@NorthernLad Haha, yeah Josh just owns it with the dialogue. "Can I hold the fucking compass??"

This is one of those movies that left me quoting it years later in random situations.

Let's not call him the Captain, you illiterate TV people. It's the Skipper.

Fisherman 1: "Anybody worth their salt around here knows that this area's been haunted by that old woman for years" Fisherman 2: "Oh, that's b*ullshit!" Love those fishermen!

Ha! Love these quotes! And what about Mary Brown!

"That's really kind of a SCARY story!"

@EddieBond 666 said:

Let's not call him the Captain, you illiterate TV people. It's the Skipper.

Yes, my favourite line :)

Of lines not yet hitherto mentioned, probably anything from Heather's tearful monologue to camera.

"......we're gonna die out here."

"I kicked that map in the creek! It was worthless"