Bespreek Come and See

I'm pretty stunned right now but there needs to be discussion about this film. There wasn't a false note from any actor, especially the two very young leads. This was Olga Mironova's only film. This was the director Elem Klimov's last film. Each sequence exuded care and quality. The sheer number of people on screen for a good deal of the film was staggering. How did a film of this enormity get made in 80s USSR?

4 antwoorde (op blad 1 van 1)

Jump to last post

To exorcise the demonic nightmares of War, tell the truth and let the bodies fall where they will. Black-and-white movies and photos of Russian civilians killed by invading Nazi forces have been seen in many documentaries since the end of World War II. For the modern "why isn't it in color?" generation, such images are distant, surreal, and uninvolving, in spite of the subject matter. Filming "barbarians in the village" with color film smacks everyone across the face (and psyche) with the "Untermenschen" attitude of, in this case, SS troops. Making the protagonist a child-trying-to-be-a-man where the war hasn't reached yet makes it personal. It's a world without morality, as the Strong steal from the Weak, and armed men "take no prisoners." Is it any wonder that one "survives" such experiences, only to have them return in dreams. There's no "Private Ryan" to save, it's more like "Fires On The Plain" as seen by civilians.

I just saw it last night, and wow, it is impressive. More than that, it's pretty soul-crushing in how it conveys the Nazis' atrocities. The only other film I can think of that has such a level of detail in conveying scenes of war involving a lot of people is The Battle of Algiers. And The Battle is so detailed, it approaches documentary quality. And yes, this film is powerfully acted. My only quibble with it is that it could've been shorter... some scenes were dragged out a bit much for me in a film that's roughly 2 and a half hours long.

@mechajutaro said:

Was unaware of this one's existence until today, and now I'm eager for a look. I take it the title is a reference to Revelation?

I believe so. I mean, I'm no Bible reader -- I find the good book incredibly boring. But I did see somewhere that the title is referring to that.

The Ruskies were no troop of boyscouts either. No one is in a war. Check out Stalingrad too.

Kan ’n rolprent of TV-program nie vind nie? Teken aan om dit te skep.

Globaal

s fokus op soekbalk
p open profielkieslys
esc sluit ’n oop venster
? open sneltoetsvenster

Op mediablaaie

b gaan terug (na ouer waar van toepassing)
e gaan na wysigblad

Op TV-seisoenblaaie

(regterpyl) gaan na volgende seisoen
(linkerpyl) gaan na vorige seisoen

Op TV-episodeblaaie

(regterpyl) gaan na volgende episode
(linkerpyl) gaan na vorige episode

Op alle beeldblaaie

a open beeldtoevoegvenster

Op alle wysigingsblaaie

t open vertaalkieser
ctrl+ s dien form in

Op besprekingsblaaie

n skep nuwe bespreking
w tokkel kykstatus
p tokkel openbaar/privaat
c tokkel maak oop/toe
a open aktiwiteit
r reageer op bespreking
l gaan na laaste reaksie
ctrl+ enter dien u boodskap in
(regterpyl) volgende blad
(linkerpyl) vorige blad

Instellings

Wil u hierdie item gradeer of tot ’n lys toevoeg?

Teken aan