Cast 23

1. 

   Hilarie Burton

   Katherine

2. 

   Tyler Hilton

   Caleb

3. 

   Randy Travis

   Mr. Greenhall

4. 

   Markie Post

   Lilly

5. 

   Ed Asner

   Papa Noel

6. 

   Brody Rose

   Zach

7. 

   Ariana Neal

   Sienna

8. 

   Cannon Bosarge

   Bryce

9. 

   Griff Furst

   Josh

10. Colin Bates

    Young Caleb

11. 

    Samantha Beaulieu

    Park Ranger Beth

12. Jacob Etter

    Flashback Kid

13. 

    Odessa Feaster

    Local Woman

14. 

    Dana Gourrier

    Janelle

15. 

    Leticia Jimenez

    Kathryn's Assistant

16. Mary Katherine Oglesby

    Young Katherine

17. Lisa Raziano

    Pageant Attendee

18. Angela M. Thomas

    Receptionist

19. Allen Boudreaux

    Store Patron (uncredited)

20. John C. Coffman

    Office Worker (uncredited)

21. Jay Florsheim

    Bonfire Goer (uncredited)

22. Bria Hobgood

    Extra (uncredited)

23. 

    Tommy Sheppard

    Bonfire Goer (uncredited)

Crew 15