Interstellar girdisini tartış

Which movie did it better?

Interstellar tied the bonds of the father-daughter relationship more intimately with the plot of the movie... But Ad Astra seems to explore more the emotional toll of how duty, purpose and expectation is tied into our relationships with our fathers...

Which space movie integrated family better? I'm leaning moreso to Ad Astra, because the theme is the purpose of the movie and it's rare to see a father son relationship involving grown up men, rather than adolescents...

2 yanıt (toplam 1 sayfanın 1.sayfasında)

Jump to last post

There are definitely many similarities of the themes found in each, but each are approached much differently, each with a stronger emphasis on different areas.

In Ad Astra, while it was a space movie, was actually more about the relationship with the father and the man's internal conflict. It seemed that the sci-fi space aspect of it was secondary, merely the story's setting, but the same story could have been told regardless of it was space or not.

Interstellar had a much stronger emphasis on traditional "space science fiction", and while the family connection did play a pivotal role in the overall story, it was more or less used as a mechanic to give depth to the conflict of the main-characters. You could conceivably tell the story without the family dynamics, and still have a very similar movie. Essentially, family is not "the" story, it is "a" story of the movie. I am struggling to find the right words to describe what I mean, right now...

For all the similarities, the movies are surprisingly very much different in my opinion. While the themes and setting sound the same on paper, watching them play out on screen and the way they are told makes comparing them like "comparing apples to oranges" as the saying goes. They are both good in their own right.

@ForeverZer0 : What a great post you wrote! While I have seen both movies, I have never thought to compare them. I thought that when it came to family relationships, Interstellar was a lot more emotional, especially in the scene where Cooper is crying as he's watching one of the videos from his family (I always cry watching that too).

Bir filmi veya diziyi bulamıyor musun? Eklemek için oturum aç.

Küresel

s arama çubuğuna odaklan
p profil menüsünü aç
esc açık bir pencereyi kapat
? klavye kısayol penceresini aç

Medya sayfalarında

b geri git (veya uygulanabilirse ana ekrana)
e sayfayı düzenlemeye git

TV sezonu sayfalarında

(sağa ok) sonraki sezona git
(sol ok) önceki sezona git

TV bölüm sayfalarında

(sağa ok) sonraki bölüme git
(sol ok) önceki bölüme git

Tüm görüntü sayfalarında

a resim ekle penceresini aç

Tüm düzenleme sayfalarında

t çeviri seçiciyi aç
ctrl+ s formu gönder

Tartışma sayfalarında

n yeni tartışma oluştur
w izleme durumunu değiştir
p umumi/hususi değiştir
c kapalı/açık değiştir
a etkinliği aç
r tartışmayı yanıtla
l son yanıta git
ctrl+ enter mesajını gönder
(sağa ok) sonraki sayfa
(sol ok) önceki sayfa

Ayarlar

Bu öğeyi derecelendirmek veya bir listeye eklemek ister misiniz?

Giriş