محادثة The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas

we have to add layers of fantastical nonsense to it. The subject matter is one that should be treated with the utmost sensitivity when creating 'art' or 'entertainment', and I had a sense as this film progressed that it was not getting the balance right, with moments such as

  • Bruno living next to a camp and being able to see it from his window
  • the lack of surveillance of the perimeter fence
  • the boy in the camp ending up being employed at the big house
  • the 8 year old's ability to dig a huge hole on either side of the fence

All used to advance the story but all completely beggaring belief. There are litterly countless angles that this topic can be approached from in film and stories that could be poignant or horrifying whilst being true to reality. Even something like Life Is Beautiful (which I, perhaps controversially, thought was excellent) handled the topic in a way that jarred a lot less with me, because it had a surrealist element and more deftly viewed things through the eyes of a child. Whereas this was straight laced and serious throughout, while introducing nonsense.

TBitSP was filled with needlessly heavy-handed moments and is one of my least favourite film on this topic. Perhaps my dislike is magnified by the lack of authentic accents, which made it hard for me to connect.

4/10

3 ردود (على هذه الصفحة 1 من 1)

Jump to last post

I actually don't mind creative liberties being applied to this particular genocide history, or any history for that matter. It all depends on what the creators want to achieve with the film.

However, I do want to express my disappointment at the ending. It's too sudden and short, an hour plus of setup with just 1-3 minutes of climax.

@Fergoose said:

we have to add layers of fantastical nonsense to it 4/10

this is a good movie with a very good lesson. too bad you werent able to comprehend, pork chop

@suburbandog said:

@Fergoose said:

we have to add layers of fantastical nonsense to it 4/10

this is a good movie with a very good lesson. too bad you werent able to comprehend, pork chop

I suspect I detected the lessons of intolerance and closed mindedness better than some. :p

لم تجد الفلم أو المسلسل ؟ سجل دخولك و انشئها

عام

s ركز شريط البحث
p افتح قائمة الملف الشخصي
esc اغلق النافذة المفتوحة
? افتح نافذة اختصارات لوحة المفاتيح

على كافة صفحات الوسائط

b ارجع للخلف (او للصفحة الام عند التطبيق)
e انتقل لصفحة التعديل

على كافة صفحات موسم المسلسل

(السهم الايمن) انتقل للموسم التالي
(السهم الايسر) انتقل للموسم السابق

على كافة صفحات حلقة المسلسل

(السهم الايمن) انتقل للحلقة التالية
(السهم الايسر) انتقل للحلقة السابقة

على كافة صفحات الصور

a افتح صفحة اضافة الصورة

على كافة صفحات التعديل

t افتح محدد الترجمة
ctrl+ s ارسال النموذج

على صفحات المناقشة

n انشى نقاش جديد
w تبديل حالة المتابعة
p تبديل عام / خاص
c تبديل اغلاق / فتح
a افتح الانشطة
r رد على النقاش
l انتقل لأخر رد
ctrl+ enter أرسل رسالتك
(السهم الايمن) الصفحة التالية
(السهم الايسر) الصفحة السابقة

الاعدادات

هل تريد تقييم او اضافة هذا العنصر للقائمة؟

تسجيل الدخول