After the poor reviews, I felt it best not to waste money seeing A:C in theaters. Since I own all of the others, even AVP:R, I knew I'd end up buying it, which is still less expensive than tickets + a soda.
Rather than re-hash every thread posted so far, I'll just pre-emptively agree with every negative opinion offered so far. To me, the film is the epitome of my chief criticism of Ridley Scott: the man can film beautiful scenery, but there isn't an ounce of humanity in his work. He contorts himself, and his writers, to tackle "big issues" but fails at every turn to understand that great characters make great movies.
From the beginning, I didn't care what happened to a single person aboard the Covenant, so how could any part of the film hold my interest? As was the chief criticism by the cast of the original Alien, Ridley Scott directs scenery and not actors. Unless the actor can bring something unique to a role, Ridley is incapable of (and disinterested in) creating characters that function as real human beings. They're just props to be lit, staged, and walked through their paces in service of an overall aesthetic.
The rest of what I disliked would simply become a screed, so I will end with an observation and a wish.
My Observation: The suit by Giger from the original film, while made of rubber, was 1,000 times more interesting and frightening than the shitty CG prop from this movie. The Alien is no longer interesting. At all. It has been beaten so badly to death by shitty CG and lame rubber suit work that I can finally say it lacks all capacity to thrill anymore. Knowing the studios, that pixel puppet is all we can ever expect in the future, so let the fucker die.
My Wish: I wish Ridley Scott wouldn't be allowed to make one single additional Alien film. Not one. He took two swings at the ball and not only did he foul it off, he nailed the catcher in the groin. Fucking stupid ideas all around.
As the title says, what a shit show. Seriously.
¿No encuentras una película o serie? Inicia sesión para crearla:
¿Quieres puntuar o añadir este elemento a una lista?
¿No eres miembro?
Contestado por Knixon
el 17 de agosto de 2017 a las 15:48
Nicely and succinctly put. Especially the parts about Scott. He gets way too much credit for the first Alien movie, the quality of the cast had a lot to do with it.
Contestado por Mackentorsk
el 18 de agosto de 2017 a las 17:58
I haven't seen the movie since it was in cinemas, but I'm unsure if I can even bother watching it again. Really dissapointed by it.
Contestado por Alfred
el 19 de mayo de 2018 a las 14:52
The first movie was no better than this POS.
Contestado por Fergoose
el 12 de abril de 2020 a las 18:09
I thought the first half was fairly decent, then it took a major dip. Pet peeves included:
It was like someone was trying to make a decent film but the studio imposed heavy handed mainstream elements to destroy any semblance of creative integrity. Colour me unsurprised.
5/10
Contestado por Billions
el 13 de abril de 2020 a las 03:05
What was the obligatory kung fu scene? I don't remember that. Maybe it would've made it better if there was one.
Contestado por tmdb53134531
el 16 de junio de 2020 a las 15:50
Reading this I thought about the Alien 3 adult Alien in its puppet form. They definitely got more out of that in terms of menace than the CGI versions of Covenant. Plus, it was an H. R. Giger 'update', with all that that entails, and what Giger added, combined with the realisation made the rubber suit Alien very frightening. I think that was because although it came out of an animal it still looked like a version of a man, a humanoid. I never liked the way in later films the effect was much more animalistic e.g. the hind legs that shouldn't be there in Resurrection — and the behaviour. Even in Aliens, as excellent as that film is, the creatures did lose something in a similar way, as if it's difficult to have many Aliens together and retain that unsettling feeling that the lone one achieves, so they end up like a pack of dogs.
Contestado por JustinJackFlash
el 16 de junio de 2020 a las 20:04
Anyone looking forward to Ridley's next installment? Alien: Pretension.
Contestado por VobIdem
el 14 de septiembre de 2020 a las 07:32
Only if corona halts production indefinitely
Contestado por MongoLloyd
el 14 de septiembre de 2020 a las 22:24
Was this the sequel to Prometheus? Man, that was just off the charts sh!t.
Contestado por VobIdem
el 16 de septiembre de 2020 a las 02:32
Vomit, diarrhea, they're both are bad and don't need comparing
Contestado por Knixon
el 16 de septiembre de 2020 a las 02:55
Well, at least you can't TASTE diarrhea. And - at least hopefully - none of it ends up in your nasal passages.
Contestado por cpheonix
el 24 de septiembre de 2022 a las 05:32
Wow, people do really hate this film. As a standalone movie I'm sure this wouldn't have got so much hate. It had great visuals with some tense moments (the first Alien coming out the back of the guy, flute playing scene) and an interesting bad guy in David.
But otherwise, I agree with the OP and others - you didn't care for the characters, the David/Walter switch was so obvious and the alien isn't terrifying or interesting anymore (maybe due to the ropey CGI).