Item: The Singing Ringing Tree
Language: en-US
Type of Problem: Incorrect_content
Extra Details: English title is locked without a comma while the German title has one. Can it be changed to The Singing, Ringing Tree since it's proper punctuation?
Film of tv-serie niet gevonden? Log dan in om deze te creëren.
Want to rate or add this item to a list?
Not a member?
Reactie van Samara
op 2 april 2022 om 7:54 PM
Is this really an official english title for this movie?
Reactie van Hec_Hall
op 2 april 2022 om 8:46 PM
Punctuation is funny and inconsistent in marketing for movies. Sometimes it is absent and other times not, usually because it's inconvenient or overlooked or because some rando just thinks it looks better without it. You can see it on the DVD from the UK here:
https://www.amazon.com/Singing-Ringing-Tree-Christel-Bodenstein/dp/B00004YS9R
But on others it is absent, like the Blu-ray from the UK.
But as the punctuation is in the German title, and the English title is the literal translation of the German, I don't see why it wouldn't be included.
Reactie van Samara
op 3 april 2022 om 6:45 AM
I think you can add it as alternative title if both are in use
Reactie van Hec_Hall
op 3 april 2022 om 7:23 PM
Sure, of course. But is the title without the comma an official English title?
Reactie van Samara
op 4 april 2022 om 6:46 AM
You wrote that both titles are in use on DVD and Blu-ray so it's okay to add them