Siyah Kristal girdisini tartış

I was struck by how little empathy Kira shows. The beings that took her in and raised her have their village raided and many of them are kidnapped to be be turned into slaves.

All Kira does is call for Jen and run away. She doesn't express a moment of sorrow, except to say 'that it always happens'.

And then she summons two landstriders to take them to the castle and then urges them into a battle they have no part in and they die and again she shows now guilt or sorrow at all.

Her complete lack of empathy suggests psychopathy, an unusual character trait for a heroine!

2 yanıt (toplam 1 sayfanın 1.sayfasında)

Jump to last post

I think you're being too hard on Kira. As a child, she experienced the very traumatic event of seeing her mother and the last of the rest of her people-- the Gelflings -- wiped out; she knows that once a village is attacked by overwhelming numbers and strength, the only option is to retreat. During the terror of the village being invaded, she naturally calls out to her lover, Jen, the last of her race, the only other being on the planet that she can reproduce with. It may sound cold, but there are other Podlings; but there is only one other Gelfling (Jen).

As for the landstriders, I remember from reading the board on the old IMDB that there were others who would agree with you-- some of the people over there thought Kira was heartless and that she viewed the landstriders only as a means to an end. But, in my view at least, the landstriders were more like horses, not intelligent beings; and we have used horses in warfare for thousands of years, yes? It was sad watching those landstriders die, but such is war-- senseless death and carnage. I do not think Kira was a psychopath, but I have no doubt, after all these events have passed, and Kira and Jen live in peace-- no doubt with offspring of their own --that their dreams will often be filled with the horrors that they participated in; but again, such is war.

Thank you, Strannger18, for posting about this film; I've noticed that you've been posting about many movies from the 1980s and 90s here on TMDB, trying to get many of the boards for older movies to be active, like they were on IMDB; my hat goes off to you:)

Thanks. It's not been easy. I've been trying to make it feel like imdb again.

Bir filmi veya diziyi bulamıyor musun? Eklemek için oturum aç.

Küresel

s arama çubuğuna odaklan
p profil menüsünü aç
esc açık bir pencereyi kapat
? klavye kısayol penceresini aç

Medya sayfalarında

b geri git (veya uygulanabilirse ana ekrana)
e sayfayı düzenlemeye git

TV sezonu sayfalarında

(sağa ok) sonraki sezona git
(sol ok) önceki sezona git

TV bölüm sayfalarında

(sağa ok) sonraki bölüme git
(sol ok) önceki bölüme git

Tüm görüntü sayfalarında

a resim ekle penceresini aç

Tüm düzenleme sayfalarında

t çeviri seçiciyi aç
ctrl+ s formu gönder

Tartışma sayfalarında

n yeni tartışma oluştur
w izleme durumunu değiştir
p umumi/hususi değiştir
c kapalı/açık değiştir
a etkinliği aç
r tartışmayı yanıtla
l son yanıta git
ctrl+ enter mesajını gönder
(sağa ok) sonraki sayfa
(sol ok) önceki sayfa

Ayarlar

Bu öğeyi derecelendirmek veya bir listeye eklemek ister misiniz?

Giriş