Dopo che sei amici da una vita hanno litigato per cinque anni, "The Bobfather", riunisce i suoi amici per i Buddy Games, una folle competizione di assurde sfide fisiche e mentali con la possibilità di vincere un piatto da $ 150.000. Ora tutte le scommesse sono scadute, poiché i tizi determinati combattono, si aggrappano e fanno festa per un sacco di soldi.

Fish has spent six years in jail. Six years alone. Six years keeping his mouth shut about the robbery, about the other men involved. The night he is released, the four men he protected with silence celebrate his freedom with a congratulatory dinner. The meal is a lavish array of sushi, served off the naked body of a beautiful young woman. The sushi girl seems catatonic, trained to ignore everything in the room, even if things become dangerous. Sure enough, the four unwieldy thieves can't help but open old wounds in an attempt to find their missing loot.

After the release of his debut film, documentarian Richard Chase journeys down a rabbit hole to uncover the lost second episode of his initial film's subject: Wise Guys.