Jamie Linden dirigirá la película a partir de un guión que él mismo ha escrito, centrándose su argumento en un grupo de amigos que se reúnen diez años después de su graduación en el instituto. Temple Hill y 33andOut Productions, la compañía de Tatum, producirán el filme.

Peter grew up on the streets of London in the late 19th century. Together with other pickpockets, he is ordered by gang leader Jimmy Hook to steal a magic ball that can transport them to another world called Neverland. There they meet a bunch of friends and enemies, including the power-hungry Elizabeth Bonny and her pirates, who are searching for the secret that can ensure eternal youth. Peter is soon faced with a problem: can one ever leave Neverland?