When Margo sarcastically tells Mr. Whiskers that she's in love with him he attempts to find a way to win her heart, so he seeks Brandy's advice. However, Brandy mistakenly believes that Mr. Whiskers is actually in love with her, much to her dismay, so she attempts to convince him to never speak to the girl he loves again. However, things take a turn for the worse when Ed gets involved and begins to fight for Margo's affection, which causes Brandy to think Ed loves her as well, though will this love triangle manage to be resolved without offending the parties involved?

When Gaspar sells Mr. Whiskers some meteor insurance in exchange for a Sugartoad poster, Brandy realizes that what Mr. Whiskers' gained was merely a toaster. She tries to tell Mr. Whiskers and when he finally believes her, he heads off to Gaspar's in order to try to get his poster back, though his attempts yield no results. Mr. Whiskers then asks Brandy for help, in which she suggests that Mr. Whiskers attempt to con Gaspar back in order to retrieve the poster, so Mr. Whiskers employs Ed and the two head off to try to trick Gaspar into giving back the Sugartoad poster.

Ed and Lola Boa have a crush on each other, so Brandy tries to make the relationship perfect, while Whiskers tries to sabotage the whole thing.